Four years on, Isabel and Gerard are still living separate lives. Gerard seems to be happy in his new life, but Isabel isn't. Does Gerard still love her? Or is it too late...

Riley Pierce was the only daughter of billionaire William Pierce and his wife Roslyn Pierce. But when they both die in a horrible accident Riley is orphaned. For over 11 years Riley has lived in Dawson Lane's Orphanage for Girls. But when 4 musicians that she is all too familiar with come to the orphanage she isn't there to see her 12th year. Soon Riley is living with Fall Out Boy being pampered beyond belief. Ezra is the boy next door, with the strap hanging from his shoulder blade and a head full of songs. Riley would be blind and stupid if she didn't fall for him. The guys are already super protective of their 'little sister' and make sure to put Ezra in his place one night warning him to be careful. What happens when Ezra doesn't take their advice? What happens when one of her 'brothers' love isn't so brotherly? What happens if she feels the same way?