An alternative sequel to A Step Back, where David and Jennifer broke up in 1998. Now it's 2013, almost 10 years after Friends ended, and Jennifer shows up at David's doorstep in New York City needing help after years of staying away from each other. They decide to ignore their past relationship and just be friends, but they take a step back and realize they can't help falling in love with each other. They rekindle that spark they once had between them, which had ended fifteen years before. They fall in love and adventure in New York City, just two middle-aged lovers learning to love again.

"His eyes are watering, he looks so broken and vulnerable, but I understand now. All of those nights where he was so sweet and tender, saying things so nice, things even my past boyfriends had never said. All of those times where he'd savor each kiss like it meant the world to him, I guess it did." - Jennifer The year is 1994 and the TV show Friends has begun filming. Once cast has become acquainted, David Schwimmer falls for his cast mate Jennifer Aniston. He longs for her to even notice him, maybe even acknowledge his existence and passion. They are best friends, never letting the other one fall. Will she ever find out, or will his love disappear and die away?