When Ava and Toby disappeared Slenderman thinks they're traitors and work for Zalgo. But in actuality, they're at Ava's old home, The mansion of the Grim Reaper. *This is unfished and probably won't be completed*

Toby is saved by Slenderman and lives now with the Creepypasta's. Because of his problems and disorders he has to go to a therapist (Masky). When meets the therapist he falls in love. Has the therapist the same feelings for him and becomes Masky also a Creepypasta? This is my first story and also my first Creepypasta. Hope you enjoy!

Timothy, the infamous Masky, writes analysis on his fellow creepypastas. He's worked his way through a good number of them, his latest being Toby Erin Rogers. However, this isn't the usual story of the two proxies hating each other, but it's in no way a fairy tale either. Follow along as Masky attempts to gain an understanding of Toby Rogers and maybe gets more than he was initially asking for.

This will not be super loving at the beginning. It will not be extremely sappy, they are killers, and they both have problems. I do not own the characters Tim or Toby.

There has always been a massive feud with Masky and Toby. Hoodie and clockwork have had enough, there going to do different things to make them friends. Clockwork helps Toby and hoodie is trying to help Masky. They find out a few things that can ruin everything they have been working on. Either they will hate each other forever, be friends, or become lovers. You will just have to read and find out. (P.s if you don't like Boy x Boy then go find another fanfiction!Also there is some cursing and maybe an inappropriate joke here or there, possibly gore.)

It has been six years since Slenderman has hired a new Proxy. And when he does, it disappoints the other Proxies greatly. How could this small, twitchy boy be a new Proxy? However, Toby is quick to prove himself to the other Proxies when Masky attempts to fight him to figure out why Slender chose him. Toby can't feel any pain. Nothing will stop him until his opponent is dead, or cute. Toby is quick to latch onto Tim since he's the only kind human in the Proxy clan. Tim doesn't want to admit it but he now sees Toby as a friend, maybe even more. However, these feelings are quickly interrupted when Tim gets a visit from his past and begins a long journey toward completing the job he never got done. And in a twist of irony, this brings Tim and Toby closer than either is willing to admit. Hoodie's there too. But he's just there to kill some people, not for the gay stuff.

"I hate you!" "Don't lie to yourself, it'll only hurt more." -------- When the arguments between Masky and Toby end, a strange attachment arises and insults turn into wounds. A tale of love, tears, and tragedy between a deluded boy and a delirious man. [Not edited; a lot of mistakes in earlier chapters but will be revised when book ends]

When the new proxy, Toby, comes to live at the Slender mansion, Masky is a little happy, but still doesn't like the idea that he has to watch over him. But what happens when Toby gets into some trouble that he didn't even cause. In this story Toby's life was is worse than any other pasta, (just an FWI) also, I made Toby have a form of autism that makes it so he's very crazy and doesn't like being touched a lot. A few curses here and there. Plus some rape. Trigger warning ⚠️

Tim and Toby are two of Slenders best proxies. Yet they're both complete opposites, well, only with the things they like. One hassling and mothering the other while one tends to run away from emotions. This is a story of how they learn to get along yet, with this comes large struggles. Will the fall in love or end as another tragedy? Disclaimer, no art belongs to me, it all belongs to their respective owners and creators. These characters are not my creation and belong to their respective creator. This is an AU where Masky and Toby do live in the same universe.

Toby has always been a nuisance, especially to Masky. Recently, something between them happened..