Oh you know the story. The new girl comes to a new high school and befriends a group of people, while slowly gaining a crush on the popular boy who messes with her...That's not what happens here. Amy and her best friend Cream decide to go to the same college, "Mobius University" but when they get there, they discover that all their friends had the same idea. Including Sonic...and his girlfriend. Sonic is shocked. Amy is confused. Drama arises. But hey, what could possibly go wrong.

You caught his eye right away. He wasn't sure what it was about you but before he even knew your name he was fixated on you. Toby's not the type to wait around for what he wants, he takes it. He wants you and he'll have you. He doesn't care if you don't like it; you're his. (Warning -Strong language -Gore -Sensitive content -The reader is written gender neutral so anyone can read it I use they/them pronouns) (Yes, I know Masky and Hoodie aren't Creepypastas but I really wanted to include them. They both belong to Marble Hornets.) (Art is not mine) Thanks for reading!💕