Oliver has returned after 5 years on a hellish Island. When he returnes home with a welcoming party, he sees someone who gets his attention.. it may be love at first sight. What will Oliver do? Who is the mysterious girl? How does this story end?

Accepting that Oliver and Sara are together, Felicity buries her feelings for him and moves on with someone else. Meanwhile, Oliver thinks he's happy until the one woman he never thought he'd want is suddenly the only thing he can think about. Set post 2x14. Story ends Olicity, but has an alternate ending with Felicity and Adam Donner.