Zara Wexler was so ready to graduate high school. She had it all planned out. She was going to go to Yale like her parents and then find the love of her life. They would travel, support their favorite causes while building their respective careers. Everything would be perfect. The thing is that nothing ever goes exactly as planned. Zara becomes confused when her crush Alyson Crawford shows an interest in her. Alyson was supposed to be straight. She has a boyfriend and her dad would probably be voted in as President of the Homophobe Club. As the school year progresses, Zara finds out how complicated love can be.

Cara Lee is cold, awkward, highly OCD and she is defininly not a people person. She spends most of her days in her luxury apartment away from any social interaction. After having two successful stories published, she has hit a writing block. Not only that, but she's losing money and the only way to keep her apartment is to get a roommate. Hannah Bailey has traveled the world and has never found a place to call home. Tired of living at her agency's model apartments, she decides to settle down in one place. She finds a beautiful apartment and the only issue with it is an unhappy roommate. Cara and Hannah come from two different worlds. Hannah represents everything Cara disliked about people. Hannah who is used to being well liked can't help, but become intrigued by Cara's indifference to her. Can she melt her new roommate's cold exterior and show her that maybe she can like at least one person?