Select All
  • FireStarter - Ticci Toby x Reader
    100K 2.2K 31

    This is my first creepypasta story so I hope you little Bolts enjoy ^^ ~~~ What would you do if a man came into your house and offered you a job as a killer? Would you go with him, fall in love with him, and sacrifice everything to keep him? Or would you knee him where the sun don't shine and call the cops? *May inclu...

    Completed  
  • Nightmare or Daydream? (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    226K 5.9K 47

    (I started this when I was about 13 so please don't hate the first half too much!) "It was you all along, looking out for me?" Toby nodded looking down. "Of course." #623 Horror - August 30 2018 #255 Ticci Toby - February 1 2019 #12 Guy x girl - June 2 2019 #85 Creepypasta x reader June 2 2019 #295 Creepypasta - Janua...

    Completed  
  • A secret love(ticci toby x reader)
    345K 12.1K 31

    Ticci-Toby fanfic for all you Creepy Pasta lovers out there! Edit 11/13/2020- plz give me some slack I wrote this in 2014 when I was 13 dear GOD

    Completed  
  • Let Me Fix You (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    323K 8.1K 31

    All my life I've been mistreated and bullied. I was ready to give up until a certain encounter changed everything.

  • Savior 》Ticci Toby x Reader {EDITING}
    548K 19.5K 23

    ~"The wind tugged at your hair as you sat on a bench and read your book. You had an uneasy feeling, like you were being watched, but you ignored it. You didn't know he was behind you."~ Living with your drunken mother had been a living hell. Everyday, you wished for nothing more than to leave. One night when you're ho...

    Completed  
  • Ticci toby X reader
    284K 7.2K 35

    Will you stay sane? or will you fall in love with a Killer Teenager? (y/n)'s Sister having to be Murders. Leaves her to join them. Having met a teenage boy with grey skin and orange goggles tried to kill her once along with her Little sister Gail, Who is also a Murderer, Might have sprouted some feelings about her. Wi...

    Completed  
  • Ticci Toby x Reader
    285K 7.7K 19

    You are in love, with Ticci Toby. The same boy who murdered your family. Are you really in love, or just crazy.

    Completed  
  • Ticci Toby x Reader
    59.4K 971 18

    A Fun And Really Romantic Book About Your Favorite Creepypasta Toby!! Enjoy

    Completed  
  • Under Control (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    215K 6.4K 37

    (May contain sensitive topics) Things never went as plan as (Y/n) hoped. Her family had dissipated, leaving her with her solemn aunt. There, she was alone and liked it that way. When she had developed bad habits of drinking, she was falling into her crumbling world. When someone pops up in her home, her world flips an...

    Completed  
  • Tic Tock ( Ticci Toby x Reader)
    188K 5.2K 26

    What will happen when you meet Toby Rogers? You read that right! The Toby Rogers, better known as Ticci Toby, a very well known killer. Will you geek out? Will you get killed? Will you fall in love? Or will you hate him? Find out in this adventurous fanfiction! {I do NOT own any of the creepypastas, nor do I own...

    Completed  
  • Ticci Toby X Reader
    2.1M 68.8K 60

    Just a simple party with friends can trigger something deep inside of you but this may attract certain attention.

    Completed  
  • The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader]
    33.9K 907 12

    Sometimes life doesn't go to plan. Sometimes the people you love, don't love you back. Sometimes, you get fed up with some people and take matters into your own hands. She's baack! By she, I mean you. (Y/N). You're back. The long awaited sequel to "A Dance With The Devil" is finally here! With a whole lot more drama a...

    Completed   Mature
  • || My One And Only || Ticci Toby x reader lemon
    99.6K 1.3K 34

    you are a depressed reader that lost your parents in a fire. you are wandering the streets and you have only one friend named annika. she was your friend since kindergarten. untell... Oh ya lots I mean LOTS of cursing... Ya cya.

  • Mine(Ticci Toby x reader)
    95K 2.3K 18

    Breaking up with someone who you known for a while can be hard. But with all this pressure of a love triangle is harder. Can you handle it all? Or will it go down to death?

    Completed  
  • creepypasta x reader neko
    366K 8.9K 34

    all your life people made fun of you abused you but now that's all about to change warning: abuse,bullying, signs of rape... don't judge me