Creepypasta
4 stories
Creepypasta x male!reader
LifeisalieHAHA
- Reads 72,970
- Votes 1,801
- Parts 8
(M/N) had a good family until his 5th birthday. Now is a killer who blames himself for his past and covers his emotions
+2 more
Distorted (Ticci Toby x male reader)
Jam4life3
- Reads 47,492
- Votes 1,137
- Parts 7
Your brother gets you in trouble but this trouble leads you to meet Lyra and Toby.
(This is a male x reader but anyone can read it to be honest 😂)
Jeff the Killer x Reader
Silent_One19
- Reads 486,231
- Votes 13,727
- Parts 16
Your parents are killed, but you killed the killer. What if the Creepypastas are impressed by your killing skills? What will happen if you met the bad boy, Jeff the Killer