Scott has been hurt too many times. But, when he and Avi find an abused Mitch lying broken and bloody on the street, he takes him in. Could Mitch be different? Could they fall in love? Is Mitch the fifth member of Pentatonix they've been looking for?
Back in middle school, Scott and Mitch were the bestest of friends until Scott left unexpectedly without explanation or warning. Left traumatised, Mitch tried his hardest to forget and did. But that was before high school when Scott mysteriously comes back. What happened? What will happen next?