Some mystery horror fanfiction stories
22 stories
Slenderman / His Brothers Sister Scenarios by EmilySkelewolf
EmilySkelewolf
  • WpView
    Reads 50,041
  • WpVote
    Votes 1,131
  • WpPart
    Parts 14
You are known by many names. DancerGirl MusicFreak 'Dance till the World Ends' and... (y/n). Aaaand... You are the younger sister of Slenderman, Splendorman, Trenderman, Stevie, and Offenderman. Good luck.
Slenderman x reader - Experiment Breach by nerdygingerteen
nerdygingerteen
  • WpView
    Reads 490,585
  • WpVote
    Votes 13,179
  • WpPart
    Parts 19
You saved me, so now I will protect you, my dear human, Those words were kept a promise by the entity you saved, And now you will stay by his side for the rest of your days.
Killer Romance [Book 1] [Jeff the Killer x Reader] [JTK] by xXDarkQueenXxRei
xXDarkQueenXxRei
  • WpView
    Reads 614,976
  • WpVote
    Votes 26,119
  • WpPart
    Parts 34
Ten days? You have ten days left to live, but in those ten days, you have to act like you're dating him. What type of situation is that? A messed up one. Petty secrets... Incumbent lies... Weird, right? You don't even know this guy and, quite frankly, you're scared to death. It almost seems like fate is tempting you, slowly luring you into a black hole of what your life will soon be. But what will happen if Jeff seems to slowly attach himself to you? Will his protective actions be enough to keep away those dirty secrets and lies that are locked away in the barricades of his mind? Some lies may just be a cover, and some truths may lead to others, but there is an even bigger picture that you may not be alive to paint. Your life is about to turn into a nightmare. How many days will you last? (The reader is identified as female in this story. However, this does not mean other gender identities cannot read this.) -+- *1st Place in Jeff the Killer 2015 Summer Creepypasta Awards (@Creepypasta_Awards)* *1st Place in Creepy/Evil/Supernatural 2015 Summer xReader FanFiction Awards (@FanFiction_Awards)* *#210 in Fanfiction* -+- First book in the Killer Romance Series. (Jeff the Killer x Reader) I don't own Jeff the Killer and I don't own you. Most of the characters presented in this book do not belong to me. Picture used in the cover isn't mine. Credit to the creator. -+- 2023 UPDATE: I wrote this story almost 10 years ago when I was a teenager. Reading back through it now, I can see so many things I wish I wrote differently. So many things that I find just... cringy. It's one of the reasons I cannot complete the series. I really wish that one day I'll rewrite this entire thing to be more sensible. For now, I hope that you can enjoy what gave me so much joy as a teen. Thank you to everyone who has come back to leave such nice comments after so many years. I will return to writing one day.
Ben Drowned: A Glitchy Adventure by SketchaCreeps
SketchaCreeps
  • WpView
    Reads 14,890
  • WpVote
    Votes 371
  • WpPart
    Parts 13
Ben Drowned is one of the youngest Creepypastas in the mansion, so he is often left behind or the one who everyone pranks. Even Slenderman treats him as a child. Ben has had enough of getting spells cast on him, and not being allowed to go out with everyone else. Ben decide to go on little adventures of his own. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dedicated to my best friend Courtney Lesa ❤️ I miss you so much and I hope you love this story as much as I do! Love you my beautiful!
You're my new game. Ben drowned x reader. by Flying_Squirrel14
Flying_Squirrel14
  • WpView
    Reads 997,800
  • WpVote
    Votes 26,712
  • WpPart
    Parts 29
A story about a boy. And you. Read on to find out more!
Forgotten Promises: A Ticci Toby X Reader by JiminniePromise
JiminniePromise
  • WpView
    Reads 339,993
  • WpVote
    Votes 7,173
  • WpPart
    Parts 14
"You promised you won't leave me, that you'll always be by my side! Don't you remember?!" "No..." - Started: 071418 Ended: 061419 11.9K words Highest Rankings: #72 in shortstory (190k+ stories) #756 in fanfiction (850k+ stories) #65 in creepypasta (61k+ stories) #10 in ticcitoby (7k+ stories) #9 in ticcitobyxreader (290+ stories) #3 in readerxcreepypasta (280+ stories) #2 in tobyxreader (90+ stories)
Ben Drowned X Reader  by ThePerfectBlur
ThePerfectBlur
  • WpView
    Reads 2,150,226
  • WpVote
    Votes 73,415
  • WpPart
    Parts 54
It's just a glitch on the computer. Nothing major. It happens to everyone. Everyone gets a virus now and then. Right?
Cruel & Blue (Eyeless Jack story) by EternalLaughter
EternalLaughter
  • WpView
    Reads 2,133,770
  • WpVote
    Votes 75,843
  • WpPart
    Parts 77
[SEQUEL to Killer Protector (Jeff the Killer story)] In the quaint town of Gracewood, Virginia, Ao Matsukochi lives comfortably with her adoptive parents and her loyal friends. For her, everyday is full of practice and optimism. Though, every person has their quirks. Sam is her best friend, who also happens to be in her head. They go hand-in-hand like partners in crime. What Ao never expected was that with an unusual friend comes unusual things. Soon she is sent into dangerous encounters, unbelievable happenings and people beyond her wildest imaginations. She always knew she wasn't so ordinary, but now she plays an important role on the stage of life and death, alongside with a special someone with a blue mask. She'll have to believe in the impossible and rethink all that's she's known to survive a war that has thrived for centuries. Dark things lie within allies and darker things lie within herself as well. Which can she face? Which can she live with? Which won't bring her to death's door? [S E Q U E L: Terrible Fates (Ben Drowned Story)] Cover art is by: Vronik-Gesso on Tumblr *****-1st Place in Eyeless Jack-***** All CreepyPastas do not belong to me unless stated otherwise.
Killer Protector (Jeff the Killer story) by EternalLaughter
EternalLaughter
  • WpView
    Reads 7,602,652
  • WpVote
    Votes 195,703
  • WpPart
    Parts 82
[1st installment of the KP Series] Elizabeth always knew she was a special sort. Her family and friends knew too. She's an introvert and feels like a weirdo wherever she goes, even in her own home. But what happens when she encounters a man known to the world as a notorious monster? Jeff the killer. She never thought he was real; only stories told at school to freak people out. And now that he's come into her life, she'll discover just why she's so special. Monsters, killers, wraiths, and supernatural entities--how special can one get? There will be love, and loss, and triumph, and hope, all for a greater purpose: The human realm needs a protector, and that's Elizabeth. --- [S E Q U E L : Cruel & Blue (Eyeless Jack story)] *****-1st Place in Jeff the Killer-***** Cover art by: Asur-Fallinplim on deviantArt Disclaimer: Most, if not all, CreepyPastas presented throughout this story do not belong to the author. All credit goes to the original creators of those characters, anonymous or not.