You're a hunter on a simple job and you meet the Winchester boys and their Angel friend Castile. Little did you know this simple meeting would lead to one of the greatest things in your life. (Castile x Reader)

This is the SEQUEL to The Playboy of Fairy Tail High. If you haven't yet read the first, it is highly recommended that you read the it, seeing as there are spoilers and it explains the beginning of this relationship(it can easily be found from my page). Thank you!! After it feels like Natsu and Lucy had gone through everything to hell and back, they feel the best has yet to come. The year isn't even over! But there's more in store for them when friends and enemies alike come and go, and one lovely little emotion is thrown around-- jealousy. Will Natsu and Lucy be able to hold out? What will come of their relationship when Natsu can't even bring himself to confront the girl who changed him and started it all? *terrible description but I swear it's better than this♡ Also super fluff [DISCLAIMER] Hiro Mashina owns all Fairy Tail characters and the original plot!! I own any OCs and the plot to this story! [THERE IS SOME STUFF THAT IS OUT OF CHARACTER, BEING THAT THIS IS ALSO IN AN ALTERNATE UNIVERSE]

Lucy Heartfilia, top 1 student of Fairy Tail High is force to be the pretend girlfriend of the campus heartthrob, Natsu Dragneel. His reason, to make his childhood friend and first love jealous. Lucy, being blackmailed, is forced to agree and sign a contract as proof of their agreement. Will they succeed? Or will they fall for each other despite the rules of the contract they signed? This story's book cover was made by my best friend/Illegitimate Twin, @12CheshireCat Credits goes to her.. :) Highest Rank: #75 in Fanfiction

Book 3.5 "It's a Nalu Life" is the continuation of Natsu and Lucy's life after book 3, "Light My Fire". (: