Creepypastafanfic Stories

362 Stories

I Wish I was Never his Friend by Maggie_Osborne
#1
I Wish I was Never his Friendby EatYourEgo
(Jtk xMale!reader you're 12 in the begining and Jeff is 13 btw and there's some light Liu x male! Reader in this as well) A family just moves into the empty home next to...
Jeff the killer x reader by toy-maker
#2
Jeff the killer x readerby worthless
as normal i make it up as i go *shrugs* TW blood, violence Jeff is a psychopath, he will be treated as such. It will be similar to joker and harly quinn sort of (kinda)
Schooled [Laughing JackxReader] by Jcreeps
#3
Schooled [Laughing JackxReader]by Jcreeps
You are a Kindergarten Teacher at a small elementary school. You love kids, and you love your job. But when a little girl from your class is murdered, you decide to take...
To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader] by Jcreeps
#4
To Live without Fear [Jeff the Kil...by Jcreeps
The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about f...
Heartless Proxy (Hoodie x Reader) by DemonGirlMe
#5
Heartless Proxy (Hoodie x Reader)by Qhim
You couldn't stop it. The evil that was taking over, you couldn't control it. You needed to kill. It was telling you to. You've done it before, so why do you stop the...
The last of me by kacebehindbars
#6
The last of meby -kace-
"Perhaps it wasn't the best idea to get acquainted with a bunch of killer's" Y/n L/n, a soon to be famous, tech loving college student, an inspiration, a thera...
𝐒𝐎𝐋𝐈𝐕𝐀𝐆𝐀𝐍𝐓──── creepypasta. by zynxsone
#7
𝐒𝐎𝐋𝐈𝐕𝐀𝐆𝐀𝐍𝐓──── creepypas...by 𝙕𝙔𝙉
𝗦𝗼 • 𝗹𝗶 • 𝘃𝗮 • 𝗴𝗮𝗻𝘁; to wander alone. ───────( creepypasta x gn! reader ) ╰─ [𝐎𝐍𝐆𝐎𝐈𝐍𝐆] ─╯ ┈➤ three college students decided to involv...
Cold Waters (BEN DROWNED X Fem Reader) by EpicLegendOfZelda
#8
Cold Waters (BEN DROWNED X Fem Rea...by Z3ldasLullaby
Y/N is a normal 17 year old girl, with a normal life and a normal family. But, what happens when she catches the eye of something not-so-normal? "So many questions...
Your Mine, Only Mine. (Homicidal Liu X Reader) by iregretsomuch
#9
Your Mine, Only Mine. (Homicidal L...by Δ
You were the girl always getting picked on. The loner, the unpopular one, the worthless one. You always thought to yourself as human trash. Worthless.. Until one day, yo...
×♪Jeff x Ben one-shots♪× by 69Benji_is_high69
#10
×♪Jeff x Ben one-shots♪×by That John Doe simp
(This is my first book. So just to know.. I'm not a good writer. Just started with writing, so.. yep I'm not from any English speaking country, so my English isn't that...
Gumdrop(Laughing Jack X Reader) {Editing In Process} by taetaechoi
#11
Gumdrop(Laughing Jack X Reader) {E...by 🍡D.C Love🍡
Wrong Gumdrop........Gumdrop ~ Laughing Jack Rankings: #3 - LjXReader This and all the rest of my X reader books are female leads! Thank you very much😊 Disclaimer: Mom...
I'm Sorry.. [TicciMask] {UNDER EDITING} by Ne0nLightzz
#12
I'm Sorry.. [TicciMask] {UNDER EDI...by Ne0n
💀status:under editing|!WORKING ON A RE-WRITE!!💀 This is a Masky/Tim Wright x Ticci Toby/Toby Rogers fanfic that I started when I was like 12 or smt,it's not the best...
Creepypasta Femboy Hooters AU by deathscrazedpuppet
#13
Creepypasta Femboy Hooters AUby Puppet
An AU of Ben DROWNED being the daily introvert young adult protagonist looking for a job for the summer, his one and closest friend he calls Jack offers him to work with...
Completed
Heart Shaped Blood Stains (Jeff the Killer love story) by SaylemHendricks
#14
Heart Shaped Blood Stains (Jeff th...by Saylem Hendricks
*Editing* - PART 1 OF 3 (Heart Shaped Blood Stains) - Kate Chambers was a sixteen year old sophomore, already moved out and on her own with her best friend Kyl...
Tic Tock ( Ticci Toby x Reader) by TheShadowKorosu
#15
Tic Tock ( Ticci Toby x Reader)by TheShadowKorosu
What will happen when you meet Toby Rogers? You read that right! The Toby Rogers, better known as Ticci Toby, a very well known killer. Will you geek out? Will you get k...
fucked up (creepypasta x y/n by kd11321
#16
fucked up (creepypasta x y/nby
y/n grow up in 12 different foster homes and this is their 13th home you may wonder why? well read to find out (all pictures are from Pinterest) ⚠️gore ⚠️
Jane X Jeff A one of a kind couple by Jeff-The-K
#17
Jane X Jeff A one of a kind coupleby Jeff-The-K
This story is about Jane after her incident and encounter with Jeff. She vowed to kill him after his wrong doings, but when she finally finds him, will she have the guts...
Living with the Creepypastas (COMPLETED) by _creepy_pasta_216
#18
Living with the Creepypastas (COMP...by jade
HIGHEST RANKING: 9/1/18 #7 in creepypastafanfic It was again a normal day for you. Thing were going fine and usual. You went home only to find your parents dead on the f...
See you again(Homicidal Liu x Reader) by bunnygutzwrites420
#19
See you again(Homicidal Liu x Read...by Ur mum
Y/N was a normal girl she up until something happened. A family moved into the neighbourhood so due to curiosity she went over and introduced herself to them. There were...
You Can't Escape...(Jeff the Killer x Reader) by The_Wishes_of_You
#20
You Can't Escape...(Jeff the Kille...by Natsu Kirai
(Y/N) is a little girl who loves to make everyone smile. She doesn't have a mother or father but, has a wonderful grandmother who watched after her for years. (y/N) was...