Creepypastaromance Stories

Refine by tag:
creepypastaromance
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddcreepypastafanfic
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddslenderman
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddromance
WpAddlaughingjack
WpAddhoodie
WpAddfanfiction
WpAddhorror
creepypastaromance
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddcreepypastafanfic
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddslenderman
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddromance
WpAddlaughingjack
WpAddhoodie
WpAddfanfiction
WpAddhorror

67 Stories

  • Walk in the Forest by Bubbles__14341
    Bubbles__14341
    • WpView
      Reads 139
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Just a Little ONE SHOT About what would happen if Toby and Ben were dating, and they had a falling out....
  • Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios by Nanny_McreepyPasta
    Nanny_McreepyPasta
    • WpView
      Reads 39,890
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    Different creepypastas, different scenarios, and you :) You're just the average person, living the mediocre life, but that is about to change when you've met the guy of your dreams. But there's something unique about this "person", something most people don't have, or in their case, don't have the guts to do. He's a killer. (this ne includes Jeff the Killer, Ben Drowned, Eyeless Jack, Masky, Hoody, and Slenderman) :)
  • Strange Love by creepypastalover10
    creepypastalover10
    • WpView
      Reads 294
    • WpPart
      Parts 5
    Kat is a young girl who gets herself caught up in strange situations with some Creepypasta's. What will all of them think when she falls for a masked cannibal. Will they except it? Or will all hell break lose?
  • toby x clockwork by jacksgirlfreind
    jacksgirlfreind
    • WpView
      Reads 246
    • WpPart
      Parts 9
    hey yalll this is my first story dont judge me also i may have a few spelling errors here and their but i try my best so yeah enjoy this story.
  • Heartless Proxy (Hoodie x Reader) by DemonGirlMe
    DemonGirlMe
    • WpView
      Reads 544,279
    • WpPart
      Parts 22
    You couldn't stop it. The evil that was taking over, you couldn't control it. You needed to kill. It was telling you to. You've done it before, so why do you stop the blade above this hooded man's chest? You stared into his glowing red eyes, for once since becoming a proxy, hesitating. "I'm not the one who wants to hurt you." Creepypasta. Hoodie x Reader. Mentions Eyeless Jack, Masky, Ticci Toby, Slenderman, and more.
  • Forbidden by Creepypastafordinner
    Creepypastafordinner
    • WpView
      Reads 351
    • WpPart
      Parts 13
    Jeff has been best friends with slender forever but now are they more than just friends.
  • Living With My New Found Family [BEN Fanfic] by Narnia-The-Killer
    Narnia-The-Killer
    • WpView
      Reads 435
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    what will happen when Nyia finds her family? When she finds 'love'? swearing and abuseive saying
  • Wake Up by caleanamajored
    caleanamajored
    • WpView
      Reads 85
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    People say that you shouldn't walk at night in this town. They say that if you do, a serial killer that lives there will appear and kill you. White skin, a bloody Glasgow smile, sunken eyes devoid of life...he'll jump out with a knife and stab you! No, you're more likely to find Jeff checking out at Bi-Mart, buying far too many frozen pizzas for one well-adjusted man to eat by himself. updates every friday (hopefully) (yes. jeff has a romance arc. i mean, its creepypasta wattpad. he does.) (cover may be subject to change, art is mine)
  • CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios by Nyghtfall
    Nyghtfall
    • WpView
      Reads 984,588
    • WpPart
      Parts 31
    CreepyPasta: Fictional Horror Characters Includes: SlenderMan; Eyeless Jack; Jeff The Killer; Laughing Jack; Lost Silver; BEN Drowned( Doctor Smiley And Homicidal Liu Have Been Added) Boyfriend Scenarios Like How You Met; How He Asked You Out; First Kiss; Etc. ((I Will Add Characters If You Comment Who You Would Like To See)) --I Do Not Own The CreepyPastas-- (( When I Put ____ Enter Your Name)) ((Reader x Male CreepyPasta)) Hope You Enjoy! !!Nothing is Edited!!
  • A Smile of an Angle That touch a Killers Hearth (creepypasta Dr.smiley's love) by Jinx_Vinx
    Jinx_Vinx
    • WpView
      Reads 4,431
    • WpPart
      Parts 13
    What can a bind girl like her do to a killers who is amused on killing and making others suffer? Can she really be the one?
  • Flipping the Scene by Chmxlrabz
    Chmxlrabz
    • WpView
      Reads 4
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    Most people fantastic about their favorite story coming true. Maybe even a character being transported Into their world, or the other way around. Enitan Schafer, a 16 year old, lives a life similar to their fictional icon, Jeffery Woods. Their life continuously goes down a winding path into an abyss. That is until the world Enitan knew changed.
  • Creepypasta Journal. by xxMusic_saved_mexx
    xxMusic_saved_mexx
    • WpView
      Reads 183
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
  • Unlikely-a creepypasta fanfic by JassyLol
    JassyLol
    • WpView
      Reads 159
    • WpPart
      Parts 5
    I'm Allysa Moore. I'm an average girl , good grades, I'll say I'm a bit attractive. This story isn't about me being bullied so bad I run away from home, no none of that. Alright, I have a bit of a dark mindset, but that's not a problem. Honestly, I go to an average school, of course the bullies there are pretty mean, and there's some gruesome scenes in this story. My mum is always out working, and my dad's a lazy bum. I'm a single child, so I regret to admit I get a little pampered. My mum and dad fight a lot, almost all the time. But It's nothing to sulk about. Me, having a dark mindset, I'm obsessed with creepypastas. Not in a "OOOH it's jeff the killer!" Kind of way, more in a, " woah, that's cool, I wish I could haunt games like that," Kind of way. Oh yeah, I love games.
  • Laughing Matter  (Laughing Jack Fic) -Completed- by CodeNameFanGRL
    CodeNameFanGRL
    • WpView
      Reads 613,035
    • WpPart
      Parts 46
    Felice Fiore Grande always had rotten luck. She never knew her biological parents, she was always stuck in the abusive or just down right creepy foster houses. And to top it off she has a strange ability to NOT die. No matter what injury is the cause of her death she always wakes up, again. Just because she can't die doesn't mean she can't feel pain, in fact every waking moment she's alive she feels nothing but pain, and as the number of times she dies increases so does the pain. So you can bet she tries to avoid getting killed at all times. One particular night, however, a group of boys 'murders' her and dumps her off in a forest. Of course she wakes up as she always does, only to have a particular psychopathic clown to stumble upon her, and take an interest in her gift, resulting in her getting stalked EVERYWHERE she goes. So her avoidance of death plan is pretty much down the drain.
  • Circus Freaks by MidnightSpider
    MidnightSpider
    • WpView
      Reads 2,577
    • WpPart
      Parts 4
    LJ ask's jack to meet him at his fair but why?
  • Trust Me ( Jeff the killer romance ) by TwistedEcho
    TwistedEcho
    • WpView
      Reads 212
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Siren, your average teenage girl.. somehow ends up in debt to a murderer. When the same kïłłęr who saved her life tries to end it, how will she react to her saint and devil?
  • Slenderman x reader by charroltin
    charroltin
    • WpView
      Reads 51,146
    • WpPart
      Parts 21
    Before you read, I don't think I'll be finishing this story sorry, it is defs ongoing but yeah read at your own risk 🥴 The story starts out as you being a 7 year old (boy or girl), you have never met your parents and thus grown up in a orphanage. But because of what happened when you where a baby, everyone in the orphanage treats you terribly. One day you encounter someone of which you never thought you would meat. THIS IS AN ONGOING STORY!!!!!! -art done by me--