Creepypastaromance Stories

Refine by tag:
creepypastaromance
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddcreepypastafanfic
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddslenderman
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddromance
WpAddlaughingjack
WpAddhoodie
WpAddfanfiction
WpAddhorror
creepypastaromance
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddcreepypastafanfic
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddslenderman
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddromance
WpAddlaughingjack
WpAddhoodie
WpAddfanfiction
WpAddhorror

67 Stories

  • A Starry Night's Sky (A Ticci Toby X Reader Fanfic) by Jay__woods
    Jay__woods
    • WpView
      Reads 761
    • WpPart
      Parts 24
    "yoυ ĸnow wнaт тнey ѕay. cυrιoѕιтy ĸιlled тнe caт." ι ѕнrυg. "yoυ're very calм ғor ѕoмeone мeeтιng a ѕтranger wнo мιgнт or мιgнт noт вe plannιng тo мυrder yoυ." нe ѕayѕ, eerιly ѕerιoυѕly. a pιng oғ ғear нιтѕ мe wнen ι noтιced тнe тwo нaтcнeтѕ aт нιѕ ѕιdeѕ... What happens when little miss Y/N watches a news story about a boy who slaughtered his parents, only to be face to face with him two weeks later?
  • Heartless Proxy (Hoodie x Reader) by DemonGirlMe
    DemonGirlMe
    • WpView
      Reads 542,324
    • WpPart
      Parts 22
    You couldn't stop it. The evil that was taking over, you couldn't control it. You needed to kill. It was telling you to. You've done it before, so why do you stop the blade above this hooded man's chest? You stared into his glowing red eyes, for once since becoming a proxy, hesitating. "I'm not the one who wants to hurt you." Creepypasta. Hoodie x Reader. Mentions Eyeless Jack, Masky, Ticci Toby, Slenderman, and more.
  • Separate Worlds (Creepypasta Romance) by Potato-ChanOwO
    Potato-ChanOwO
    • WpView
      Reads 51
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    Mae and Rachael are two of the most notorious killers in the state of Maine. Mae is a hitman while Rachael kills anyone who does her wrong. One day, they find each other after the same target. After that, they become best friends and are one of the most famous killer duo's. This caught the attention of a woman named Ms. Pencil Neck. She then took the two into a mansion for female killers. And so, the adventure begins.
  • CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios by Nyghtfall
    Nyghtfall
    • WpView
      Reads 975,381
    • WpPart
      Parts 31
    CreepyPasta: Fictional Horror Characters Includes: SlenderMan; Eyeless Jack; Jeff The Killer; Laughing Jack; Lost Silver; BEN Drowned( Doctor Smiley And Homicidal Liu Have Been Added) Boyfriend Scenarios Like How You Met; How He Asked You Out; First Kiss; Etc. ((I Will Add Characters If You Comment Who You Would Like To See)) --I Do Not Own The CreepyPastas-- (( When I Put ____ Enter Your Name)) ((Reader x Male CreepyPasta)) Hope You Enjoy! !!Nothing is Edited!!
  • Creepypasta Journal. by xxMusic_saved_mexx
    xxMusic_saved_mexx
    • WpView
      Reads 181
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
  • Two Black Hearts by Killjoy_Of_Doomsday
    Killjoy_Of_Doomsday
    • WpView
      Reads 2,521
    • WpPart
      Parts 10
    Trouble can arise when bloody love is present.
  • Mysterium by deathsinmyfingertips
    deathsinmyfingertips
    • WpView
      Reads 9
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    The faint laughing is all they hear before they begin a slow and painful death, or if she's feeling merciful, she'll make it quick and make your brain explode. Mysterium, known in her first life as Hailie, little hero, is a reborn serial killer. A girl who is scared of the dark and of thunder. A girl who hunts down those who hurt others. She searches for new victims on a weekly basis. She tells her victims how their going to die, and haunts her them to insanity before ending their lives. But she likes games too. If you figure out who she is before the day of your death she leaves you alone. She makes it easy by always leaving her first death scars in the open. Will anyone figure it out before she kills them? A book full of killing games and a strange romance between two insane people that happen to stumble upon each other by accident. Let the games begin. (OKOK, if you're wondering why I say creepypasta it's because I'm a total Masky fangirl, so he will be appearing in this book, and a few other characters as well... happy reading :) )
  • Ally Glitch by AllyGlitch_EmoisLove
    AllyGlitch_EmoisLove
    • WpView
      Reads 1,186
    • WpPart
      Parts 19
    Hi im Ally Glitch and im telling you how i became a creepypasta/OC My Creater is Alicyn Shaw :)
  • Wake Up by caleanamajored
    caleanamajored
    • WpView
      Reads 78
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    People say that you shouldn't walk at night in this town. They say that if you do, a serial killer that lives there will appear and kill you. White skin, a bloody Glasgow smile, sunken eyes devoid of life...he'll jump out with a knife and stab you! No, you're more likely to find Jeff checking out at Bi-Mart, buying far too many frozen pizzas for one well-adjusted man to eat by himself. updates every friday (hopefully) (yes. jeff has a romance arc. i mean, its creepypasta wattpad. he does.) (cover may be subject to change, art is mine)
  • The Creepy Pasta House by brielikesbands
    brielikesbands
    • WpView
      Reads 242
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    A blue haired girl named Aurora is being chased down by Slenderman until she falls and passed out, she then wakes up in the Creepy Pasta House. A long life is ahead of her, with ups and downs around every corner, love with wiggle its way in eventually, but will Aurora find the one she really wants out of these guys?
  • Awake: A Creepypasta Story by -_Valerie-U_Writes_-
    -_Valerie-U_Writes_-
    • WpView
      Reads 25
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    I'm trying real hard not to shake. I'm biting my tongue, But I'm feeling alive and with every breathe that I take, I feel like I've won. You're my key to survival. And if it's a hero you want, I can save you. Just stay here. Your whispers are priceless. Your breathe, it is dear. So please stay near. Will you stay awake for me? I don't wanna miss anything I don't wanna miss anything I will share the air I breathe, I'll give you my heart on a string, I just don't wanna miss anything. Say my name. I just want to hear you. Say my name. So I know it's true. You're changing me. You're changing me. You showed me how to live. So just say. So just say, That you'll stay awake for me. I don't wanna miss anything. I don't wanna miss anything. I will share the air I breathe, I'll give you my heart on a string, I just don't wanna miss anything Imagine being followed by two killer/yandere types that are trying to save your life from a demon overlord. Yep, welcome to my life. Me and my friend have some...peculiar people following us, trying to protect us. See how well that'll work out....
  • You Shouldn't Have Done That (A Ben Drowned Romance)  by sweetserenade4life
    sweetserenade4life
    • WpView
      Reads 17
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    "The haunted Majora's Mask Cartridge. Have you heard of it?" Vanessa is possibly the only person in her whole school who has never heard of the creepypasta known as Ben Drowned. When she stumbles upon the haunted cartridge upon her locker, she decides to find out who BEN really is. As soon as she places the game in her console, things will never be the same for her. Will BEN be out to kill her or will he feel something different towards her?
  • toby x clockwork by jacksgirlfreind
    jacksgirlfreind
    • WpView
      Reads 237
    • WpPart
      Parts 9
    hey yalll this is my first story dont judge me also i may have a few spelling errors here and their but i try my best so yeah enjoy this story.