Fatherpaul Stories

Father paul x reader Oneshots I do not own any of the characters of midnight mass it is only intended for creative purposes. I will try and make y/n as vague as possible in order for you to be included mkay ☺️

Aria is a girl who lived a...ok life in Oregon. her divorced parents decided it would be better for her to move back with her father to her childhood home, Crockett Island. she finds out disturbing things. many that were part of her childhood.

When Sarah "Sadie" Miller left Crockett Island at seventeen, she never planned to come back. Not after the bruises. Not after the whispers. Not after an entire town watched her survive and called it none of their business. But years later-with a veterinary degree, a sharp tongue, and both parents buried-Sadie returns to take over her grandfather's clinic on the isolated fishing island that raised her. Crockett remembers her. And worse, it remembers what it failed to do. Then Sheriff Hassan arrives with his quiet grief, his guarded son, and an unsettling habit of showing up exactly when Sadie least wants someone around. He mistakes distance for respect. She mistakes loneliness for safety. And somewhere between hurricane warnings, town council meetings, late-night walks home, and the slow unraveling of Crockett Island itself, they begin to learn that caring for someone is not the same thing as losing them. But on an island built from secrets, guilt, and faith, love does not arrive gently. And neither do storms.

there are far worse things awaiting man than death. Midnight Mass