Jayxmatthew Stories

15 Stories

jay x matthew (big mouth fanfic) by greenhashisblue
#1
jay x matthew (big mouth fanfic)by chloe <3
Jay x Matthew - Big Mouth fanfic ft. Jessi x Missy Yeah, I'm sorry this is super gay...
Completed
Who said we couldn't be together by levineue
#2
Who said we couldn't be togetherby Levine
THIS IS A BOYXBOY SO UF YOU'RE UNCOMFORTABLE LEAVE THANK YOU💜!
Completed
Jatthew Oneshots by yutlungismylord
#3
Jatthew Oneshotsby yutlungismylord
Oh I'm so original with this idea about writing Jatthew oneshots (that sarcasm) But yeah this is random ideas I had about Jay and Matthew usually consisting of rewrites...
Young, Gay and Sweet by AutisticWriterHomie
#4
Young, Gay and Sweetby NBtistic
Jay lives with Matthew. Yay. And they share a bedroom. Double yay. But Jay soon discovers that the sassy old Matthew actually has a sweet side. Tripple. Fucking. Yay.
Jatthew. Big mouth, !sex, kissing, gayness, cringe! by YourLocalFnafLover62
#5
Jatthew. Big mouth, !sex, kissing...by YourLocalFnafLover62
2 men fall in love at a school sleepover, little do they know, the kiss starts a relationship.
Jay x Matthew fanficion  by _ButtersxKenny_
#6
Jay x Matthew fanficion by _ButtersxKenny_
So....I'm finally making one of these and warning, I'm a horrible writer! like seriously horrible. this might have a lot of typos in it and I apologize in advance. The s...
Big Mouth Nick x Andrew + Other Oneshots by techno_bacon
#7
Big Mouth Nick x Andrew + Other On...by ✨bbcarot✨
Just some oneshots, mainly Nick and Andrew, but also other ships like Jay x Matthew, and also Connie x Maury :) No smut
Icebreaker by shortcakeswan
#8
Icebreakerby shortcakeswan
He hates his family. He hates every relationship he's had. He hates himself. Matthew Macdell is drowning. And this time, there's no way out.
Rewriting Matthew and Aiden Break Up Storyline  by yutlungismylord
#9
Rewriting Matthew and Aiden Break...by yutlungismylord
I decided to rewrite Matthew and Aiden break up, from Big Mouth, and make it less toxic, so this take place in season 5 episode 3.
You're My Star - A Big Mouth Musical Fanfiction by AceSpaceLegend
#10
You're My Star - A Big Mouth Music...by Fabi
Matthew joins a theater group and finds many great new (and old?) friends there. And maybe even more? After all, he is over Jay, right? Right?
Matchmaking someone with Jay,  that isn't a pillow. by yutlungismylord
#11
Matchmaking someone with Jay, tha...by yutlungismylord
Ali, Missy and Jay are, surprisingly, friends. And they're the type of friends that no matter how much Missy gets annoyed with Ali and Jay, or Ali is reminded that she...
out of my league- A JAYTHEW FANFIC by Ecinsfears
#12
out of my league- A JAYTHEW FANFICby EC
a Jaythew fic I know you all want.
Jay x Matthew/ jatthew  by 25penguin
#13
Jay x Matthew/ jatthew by 25penguin
It's all fluff and I lil smut I promise no sad things 🤗
Jay and Matthew (Jatthew) tickle Fan-Fiction! by StenzelShipper2100
#14
Jay and Matthew (Jatthew) tickle F...by Rebecca J Brown
Nick, Andrew, Matthew and Jay have a sleepover at Matthew's house. Nick and Andrew fall asleep out of boredom but Jay and Matthew were awake and not even tired. They bot...
Jay x Matthew big mouth forbidden love oneshot (jaythew) by Narman266
#15
Jay x Matthew big mouth forbidden...by Narman266
Jay one day realized he was in love with Matthew after he realized he was hotter than him...
Completed