#1
-Fallen Angel-by Kai/kyrou
"The devil is real, and he's not some man with horns and a tail. He can be beautiful, after all he's a fallen angel and he used to be God's favourite." -Leah A...
#2
Bad Choices ⚘ Benny Weirby winter
After learning that the supernatural exists in Whitechapel Ivy, Benny and Ethan are trying to live a normal teenager life in high school with vampires and other strange...
#3
My Girlfriend's a Vampireby Levi
An Ethan Morgan x Reader story.
(Y/n) Weir, twin to Benny Weir. Watch her face her crush on her brother's best friend, and her own insecurities and fears about herself.
Completed
#4
Limerence // Erica Jones //by NeutralChaos98
After the events with Jessie Ethan and Benny thought things would settle down; dealing with certain supernatural beings becoming an everyday routine. When their childhoo...
#5
Witchcraftby Levi
A Benny Weir x Reader Story.
(Y/n) (L/n), shapeshifter. She can be anything, everything at once. When she meets people she remembers from her childhood, what happens whe...
Completed
#6
𝐍𝐢𝐫𝐯𝐚𝐧𝐚 || Rory Keanerby 𝖊𝖑𝖑𝖊
When Ethan Morgan's twin sister gets turned into a vampire whilst at a party and her feelings for her best friend come out.
Or
When Elizabeth and Rory get turned into va...
#7
Wicked (Benny Weir)by 💚Maya Weasley💚
Benny Weir x Oc
I don't own any of the babysitters a vampire characters 💕
Highest Ranks
#1-sara
#1-mybabysittersavampire
#1-mbav
#1-erica
#1-rory
#1-bennyweir
(If you...
#8
My Little Geek (mbav Rory x F!Read...by alexism0803852
You're the new girl at White Chapel High School, and you're kind of a nerd. No one really wants anything to do with you. That is until you meet Rory and his friends. Wha...
#9
soda tabs || rory keanerby anon_author13
"you are such a dork"
"come on... you love me"
Althea Weir, sister of Benny Weir.
Rory Keaner, friend of Benny Weir.
A secret affair between the t...
#10
Ice Queen - Benny Weirby Star_Wars_Nerd10
Famous actor and musician, Madelyn Julia Wilson aka Ice Queen, is getting a chance to go to a normal school. How could she pass it up? Live a normal life, well some what...
#11
LOVESTRUCK /// BENNY WEIRby Jules
After being found after having been missing for eight years, Malia's father decides she needs a change in scenery and sends her to live with her aunt in Whitechapel (of...
#12
Dusk Till Dawn - Sarah Foxby WhatintheHale17
Ryleigh James was just starting out her freshman year with her two best friends, Ethan Morgan and Benny Weir. When Ethan needs a babysitter, their Freshman year takes a...
#13
LIMERENCE ⇢ BENNY WEIRby ˗ˏˋ louise ˎˊ˗
limerence
/ˈlɪmɪrəns/
the initial exhilarating rush of falling in love.
Completed
#14
Best Friends | Benny x Readerby ☆Alanna☆
Y/n has been best friends with Ethan and Benny since they met. They have been the Geek Trio for quite a while. When the supernatural starts popping up out of nowhere and...
#16
𝙽𝚘 𝚆𝚊𝚢 (𝙱𝚎𝚗𝚗𝚢 𝚆𝚎𝚒𝚛 �...by 𝚓𝚊𝚣𝚣𝚢
"𝚆𝚘𝚠, 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢'𝚛𝚎 𝚋𝚘𝚝𝚑 𝚜𝚘 𝚜𝚝𝚞𝚙𝚒𝚍."
•••
Y/n L/n has been friends with Benny and Ethan since they were kids. Thrown into a supernatural world of...
#17
Vampire Ninja -Rory Keaner x Readerby ★Vee★
A RORY KEANER X READER STORY
Moving In with your Cousin Ethan and Experiencing a crazy first day between a weird flirt and Drama Club kids.
You're in for a ride at whit...
#18
𝑊𝑖𝑡𝑐ℎ𝑒𝑠 𝑎𝑛𝑑 𝑉𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑖𝑟�...by Maria
Camille knew that there was gonna be a change in her life, but she thought it would just be starting high school. She never expected to find out about Vampires and witch...
#19
YOUTH ⇢ BENNY WEIRby ˗ˏˋ louise ˎˊ˗
❝ MY YOUTH IS YOURS ❞
[based on the movie of my babysitter's a vampire]
[ranked 3rd in 'benny weir']
Completed
#20
Voodoo Doll//Benny Weirby multifangirl19
"I don't wanna stay I wanna run away but I'm trapped under your spell"
-*-
Benny and Mckenzie had a complicated relationship to say the least. They teased and...