Mylittleponycreepypasta Stories

49 Stories

Always Watching by Creepypastapony1
#1
Always Watchingby Axel
Tender Taps has grown tired of having his love be casually dismissed by Applebloom. She claims to only see him as a friend even with all their time dancing together over...
In The Cave by Creepypastapony1
#2
In The Caveby Axel
Rainbow stumbles upon a cave in the everfree forest while trying to get away from a strange creature.
Pinkie Promise ? by Creepypastapony1
#3
Pinkie Promise ?by Axel
Cheese Sandwich has come back to Ponyville to find Pinkie Pie punishing somepony for breaking a Pinkie Promise. Soonafter, the duo learns they have killing in common (wh...
My Little Pony SNES 2.  by SplendidPony626
#4
My Little Pony SNES 2. by SplendidPony1998
This is a story that is said to be a sequel (either fanmade or official) to the creepypasta story called My Little Pony SNES.