Natsby Stories

30 Stories

Forebidden Love  by JayXNickforever
#1
Forebidden Love by Laura
Two Gays in the 1920s, navigating their feeling for each other.
A Night Without Gatsby by EqualAdvantage
#3
A Night Without Gatsbyby EqualAdvantage
[COMPLETED] 'This is all just a fantasy. This is a child's playbook. There's no way this can be real...' Nick's reality is slowly turning to a fantasy, thanks to a cert...
Addiction by gatsbyindenial
#4
Addictionby Enoch
Gatsby struggles with an addiction and Nick tries to help him get better. All characters belong to Fitzgerald. This is in Nick and Gatsby's POVs, it will state which at...
The Green Light by michacos_y_not
#6
The Green Lightby Micha
In an alarming turn of events, Nick Carraway finds himself saving the life of his closest friend, Mr. Jay Gatsby. With harboured feelings concealed, the two try to conti...
MultiFandom oneshots by BumblebeeSkies
#7
MultiFandom oneshotsby BumblebeeSkies
Supernatural Marvel/ Batfam Sherlock Hamilton Be more chill / Dear Evan Hansen Emo trinity The Umbrella Academy Others!!!!!!!!!!!
Natsby modern times high school au by Whyme12w
#8
Natsby modern times high school auby Whyme12w
Nick Carroway is a high school student. He's not very popular and he only has one friend, Jordan. But all that changes when he meets Jay Gatsby. Jay Gatsby introduces hi...
Oneshots - Ship Book by Blackcat390
#9
Oneshots - Ship Bookby Blackcat390
I've read quite a few LGBT books (and others) and I always end up wanting the story to continue. So I decided to write my own. Collection of oneshots from various fandom...
My Confession, Old Sport by MissyMemelord
#11
My Confession, Old Sportby Missy Memelord
Literally just a natsby fanfic cause why not (Also made for a good friend of mine)
Paradise Bond  by I-wanna-cri
#12
Paradise Bond by mayoi.jpg
Sometimes when reading a book that you are force to read, you entertain yourself by writing a fanfic about said book. Here is The Great Gatsby, but in my style and tast...
The Comfort of Yesterday (And the Uncertainty of Tomorrow) - The Great Gatsby by thatriveringeorgia
#14
The Comfort of Yesterday (And the...by Styx and Bones
Jay Gatsby is supposed to be dead. So is Nick Carraway. After months of loneliness and grief, Nick and Gatsby wake up in West Egg - again, and again, and again.
Blood Diamonds (Natsby) by whatthehonkkkkkkkk
#15
Blood Diamonds (Natsby)by anna
After Nick Carraway helps Jay Gatsby get away with the murder of George Wilson, they keep up their facades while undercover as hitmen in the East Egg. As their connectio...
Thus Rises the Moon (A Gatsby Fanfiction) by verydisgustingthumb
#16
Thus Rises the Moon (A Gatsby Fanf...by Salad_Dish
**Description subject to change** This is a Gatsby fanfiction. This contains canon divergence and different plot points from the original book by F. Scott. Fitzgerald. I...
The Gayt Gatsby by Acewolf31
#17
The Gayt Gatsbyby Acewolf31
The Great Gatsby, but I amplified the gayness so its even more obvious.
Nick Carraway: And I Still Love Him by FaiFai058
#18
Nick Carraway: And I Still Love Himby Fairouz Ouikhlfen
Nick Carraway, the narrator in "The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald is back to give us a short reflection on his summer on Long Island. This is a songfic...