Payjayii Stories

*ONGOING* Hi! Thanks for reading! This is gonna take place during the events of Inanimate Insanity Invitational before and after Oj's elimination, but alot will be expl...

● ! All characters are by Adam Katz, creator of Inanimate Insanity ! ● Ever since Payler and OJ (Oliver Jay) had seperated their ways after their elementary days, they'v...

After a devastating break up, Paintbrush found themself growing closer with their friend Silver Spoon. But as his feelings for them grow stronger, how much longer can it...

Paper finds oj very attractive, and one day, a party was held, right in the middle of the party, oj had an idea to play 7 minutes in heaven with everyone and him and pap...

balloon and nickel date each other when suddenly nickel starts being more and more distant and balloon doesn't know why.

I need to write out my hyper fixation on this pair..

TW: BLOOD/GORE!!!! And I know the timeline is a little crazy...... Trophy unexpectedly traps 6 contestants and they're in what looks like a normal 'safe' room...they fin...

i just felt like making random object show ship fics so here we are

Based off a comment on "Luckily yours!"

𓊈દᵕ̈૩Just a quick PayJay oneshot for fun!⠒̫⃝𓊉 ✩•̩̩͙*˚ What would I do without you, paper..˚*•̩̩͙✩ Sure paper and OJ are best friends, that's just what paper thinks. Wh...