Timmyxgary storie

Remy and Gary both have a crush on Timmy. They won't stop fighting over him. Timmy has a crush on both boys. Timmy while have to choose which one he has to be with. Who will Timmy pick?

From the moment Timmy's mind poofed him into existence Gary had loved him. Even when their connection faded, even for the five years that he was locked away in Timmy's brain, and even for the treacherous timmyless time he spend on the island of unwished wishes he loved him. Follow Gary on his quest for his other half.