Tobyrodgers Stories

Refine by tag:
tobyrodgers
WpAddticcitoby
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddslenderman
WpAddhoodie
WpAddmasky
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddfanfiction
tobyrodgers
WpAddticcitoby
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddslenderman
WpAddhoodie
WpAddmasky
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddfanfiction

28 Stories

  • It's just us. (Ticci Toby x Fem!Reader.) by CREEPYPASTA-H0E
    CREEPYPASTA-H0E
    • WpView
      Reads 7
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    HIGHSCHOOL AU! Then from then on. TOBIAS ERIN ROGERS X FEM!READER HEAVILY INSPIRED BY HEY HONEY! @/AURORAUXX ON WATTPAD PLEASE READ IT. Go check it out it's in my reading list on my pfpπŸ’—
  • Crazy in love by xxAWKWARDTURDLExx
    xxAWKWARDTURDLExx
    • WpView
      Reads 26
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    Toby Rodgers got sent to an asylum for murdering his parents but what will he end up getting into when all his friends are murdered?
  • What Was Never Said|| Sequel to 'One Fluid Motion' by TicciToby_Lover
    TicciToby_Lover
    • WpView
      Reads 619
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    And it was quiet. Too quiet. But they couldn't do anything about it because what was done... was done and they were to late. And no matter how hard they try to fill the silence, they're still left with the deafening sound of quietness. Toby was gone, but the guilt stayed put. Sequel to 'One Fluid Motion'. Please enjoy and feel free to comment/vote/share.❀️
  • ~Ticci Toby's Story~ by _-_-jana_-_-
    _-_-jana_-_-
    • WpView
      Reads 81
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    β†ͺ~this is the story of how toby rodgers {ticci toby} became a proxy and bagan to work for slenderman~↩
  • Toby Rodgers X Oc/you by Sleppybunz
    Sleppybunz
    • WpView
      Reads 26
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    i literally don't have anything to put here, but like enjoy it i guess and yes i made the art on the cover if it shows up damn
  • Sunshine | Ticci Toby by blondemomentt
    blondemomentt
    • WpView
      Reads 19
    • WpPart
      Parts 7
    2023 - Marina is a wealthy girl with lots of friends. Her closest friend, Violet, adores horror stories-especially the one about Tobias Rogers. When Marina's father is murdered, she ends up having to make a choice: Toby or life.
  • Love at First Stab? (Ticci Toby x Reader) by CreepyNoodle14
    CreepyNoodle14
    • WpView
      Reads 749
    • WpPart
      Parts 8
    Ticci Toby, also known as Toby Rodgers, was out on his nightly kill. He broke into a small home in the nearest town. Inside the home resided a young woman. She lived all alone, with just her cat. After tormenting her for a while, Toby ended up taking her with him to a mansion hidden deep within the woods. He decided he wanted to torment her more, before he killed her. Toby normally wouldn't hesitate when killing. It was confusing for him, to say the least. Something about this girl caught his attention and wouldn't let go. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Hi! Im CreepyNoodle14! This is my first story on this account. I have another Wattpad account, but now some of my friends from real life follow it. I would be really embarrassed if they saw my work, therefore I made a new account for my writing. This is my second time in the CreepyPasta fandom! I hope you guys like it! Also, if a creepypasta you really like doesn't appear in the story, I might not know enough about them to confidently write about them. If you want me to add a character to the story, tell me their name and link me their story in the comments! Also, sorry if this story sucks. Im not the best writer, and I haven't written for others in a long time. I only write for myself usually. I hope you like this story! Ticci Toby belongs to Kastoway The cover art belongs to the very talented 0ktavian on DeviantArt.com
  • Ticci Toby X Reader by Travisthebomb1273
    Travisthebomb1273
    • WpView
      Reads 21
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    Hope you enjoy!!!!!!! ;3
  • Trust Taken and Given by xxwhitewolfgirlxx
    xxwhitewolfgirlxx
    • WpView
      Reads 14
    • WpPart
      Parts 5
    A girl named Ashley has known Toby Rodgers for years and has felt like she was in love with him.But when he changes does she still love him or will she leave him never to talk to him again.
  • Ask TicciToby! by _XxCreepstaxX_
    _XxCreepstaxX_
    • WpView
      Reads 50
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
    Hey guys I'm TicciToby! Ask me questions!
  • Demon Blood by janetheprettykitty
    janetheprettykitty
    • WpView
      Reads 727
    • WpPart
      Parts 16
    Having the Blood of a Demon can go unnoticed your entire life, but with enough anger, it can take control. Christine Stone is a college student who gets thrown into a world of chaos and blood. With new enemies, friends, and lovers, life just got a little more complicated. (Ticci Toby and Jeff the killer love triangle) β€’updated almost dailyβ€’
  • Ask Ticci-Toby by TicciErinRogers
    TicciErinRogers
    • WpView
      Reads 30,407
    • WpPart
      Parts 25
    Ask me anything you want! (I don't feel like writing my tics or stuttering, mainly because I'm writing!
  • i rewrote ticci tobys orgin cause i was bored by geekedupronn
    geekedupronn
    • WpView
      Reads 6
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    BREAKING NEWS! local autistic man rewrites a pre-made story cause they thought itd be super cool! please dont copywright mee!!
  • AT FIRES HAND. Ticci Toby x MALE Reader by aaaaaaKILLME777
    aaaaaaKILLME777
    • WpView
      Reads 362
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    dont fuckin read if your a girl. you make me sick honestly. this will include homophobia, sexualization, cursing, gore and more.READ AT OWN RISK!! It will be sad at some points. Friends bullied together to something deeper and darker, separated then reunited once more, a fire that burns may not always go out.
  • Mischievous Love by BadbunnyPuPu
    BadbunnyPuPu
    • WpView
      Reads 29,665
    • WpPart
      Parts 11
    This is a story between two stained souls, one a 25 year old man Tim Sutton aka Masky and a 19 year old boy Toby Eren Rogers, aka Ticci Toby -------------------------------------- I don't know if I will have adult content in this fanfiction yet. I just let the words flow, even I don't know how this story will end, or how it will get to this end.
  • A secret love(ticci toby x reader) by allthegayallday
    allthegayallday
    • WpView
      Reads 348,905
    • WpPart
      Parts 31
    Ticci-Toby fanfic for all you Creepy Pasta lovers out there! Edit 11/13/2020- plz give me some slack I wrote this in 2014 when I was 13 dear GOD
  • Soft Spot (TicciTobyxJeffTheKiller) by TicciToby_Lover
    TicciToby_Lover
    • WpView
      Reads 43,314
    • WpPart
      Parts 12
    This is a Story about a depressed, broken teenager named Toby... and a jack ass teenager named Jeff. Toby has always been a little strange. You would always see new little cuts along his body, and if you asked about them, he'd always say that he just fell. Jeff was a rather bitchy boy, but is still popular with the other creepypastas. Toby on the other hand, barely talks, cries a lot, and very difficult to talk to. But what happens when the rude killer meets this scared, broken young boy? Hope you enjoy, love you all!!!
  • more than my own life a masky x toby story by maskylilly
    maskylilly
    • WpView
      Reads 1,972
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    what happens when two people who had never expressed love before fall for each other. especially when their two male serial killers. find out in 'more than my own life.'
  • Emeralds - A Toby Rodgers x O/C [paused] by jeffrey_woods69
    jeffrey_woods69
    • WpView
      Reads 21
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Crystal was an ordinary teenage girl, good house great parents... great family environment... well to everybody else. Her parents always fought, sometimes Crystal or her little 9 year old brother Jake would get involved by being in the wrong place at the wrong time. She wished for them to be the family everybody thought they were... Toby has had some trouble in the past, things happened and he had stopped killing all together.. but after a while, he decides to try it again. Only to find his victim was Crystal Rose...... He finds he is unable to kill her, and he doesnt. He ends up going by the home very often, without thinking about it.. and that leads to many other things after that.
  • Obsidian heart Ticci Toby x Depressed! Artist! Reader by notwilight
    notwilight
    • WpView
      Reads 3,426
    • WpPart
      Parts 24
    "Would it matter if I wasn't born in the first place, I'm nothing, I'm not special..." "Why do I need a social life? I have the voices in my head to keep me company..." (Y/N) was not the person you would expect in a middle school. She was sad all the time while her peers were all happy. She would sit by herself, reading, to get her mind off of reality, but it never worked... She was bullied even abused at home she wanted to escape everything.... She ran away. Now she is free. Or so she thought... WARNING: trigger warning, suicidal thoughts, swearing, depression. Don't like, don't read