
#1
Touch; Ticci Toby X Readerby 𝓡𝓪𝓲𝓷☂
[Completed] Y/N is a 17-year-old girl who has been isolated in a Mental Institution for 3 years now, every passing hour becoming a blur. Days are long, but nights are ev...
Completed

#2
Forgotten Promises: A Ticci Toby X...by (✿◕▿◕)∘₊✧
"You promised you won't leave me, that you'll always be by my side! Don't you remember?!"
"No..."
-
Started: 071418
Ended: 061419
11.9K words
Highest...
Completed

#3
Why am I in a creepypasta fanficti...by FlyingSax
The 2010's, where everyone was a cringe teenager who wanted to live in Slendermansion with a bunch of other mentally ill teenagers. Now its 2024, your 23 now and grown...

#4
Beyond the Realms of Reason (Troll...by Mira
A human from our world gets teleported to the trollhunters show. Now they must find a way home without destroying the series they know and love. But will they come to li...

#5
We Get What We Want (Yandere Proxi...by Jesse Quiles
They had just got done putting (Y/N)'s ex friend/enemy and her ex boyfriend in their torturing devices.
"Who are you!? What do you want!?! Let them go!!!!" She...
Completed

#6
𝐓𝐢𝐜𝐜𝐢 𝐓𝐨𝐛𝐲 𝐱 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝𝐞�...by aurora.
"I told you the night you tried to kill me; he's not your God."
Sequel to An Eye For An Eye.
Years after The Subordinate is closed, Y/N attempts to rebuild h...
Completed

#7
creepypasta x readerby dreamypup
One day, ( y/n ) decides that she is done with her mother's abuse. She sneaks out of the house during the dead of the night, only to be met with two masked figures and a...

#8
Ticci Toby x Readerby Noggot
(DISCONTINUED - may make a new series)
Y/N is the daughter of a business man who travels around the world for his job every half a year. She's met all sorts of people, b...

#9
Let Me In || Ticci Toby x Readerby monochrome_beauty
Paranoia takes over her. It consumes her every waking hour. All she wants is an escape. But he is what makes her stay.
Warning: Intentional starvation is included in cha...

#10
A New Life? (Yandere!Toby x Oc!Rea...by Crimson
DISCONTINUED
Please dont read this fanfic is horrible.
You never understood why your life was so fucked up! Why? Why did your life have to be so different then others. Y...
Completed

#11
Forgotten Promises: The Revisionby (✿◕▿◕)∘₊✧
"You promised a lot of things to me. You must remember at least one of them, or at least remember me. Are you sure you don't remember any-"
"I'm sorry. I...

#12
Look at you~ || toby x reader x ey...by Darkcatabi
You only murdered one person in your life and they deserved it that's what you kept telling yourself they deserved it but as you died not from old age but you were kille...

#13
Run, Go Ahead. But I'll Always Fin...by Shadow/Anon E. Mos
(Y/n) is a normal person. She loves her little brother, Jean (pronounced Shawn). She loves him with all of her heart. One day, their lives change as they are kidnapped b...

#14
(DISCONTINUED) Creepypasta 7 minut...by Noggot
The story will include (hopefully I can't guaretee cause I might get lazy and give up on this story) EJ, Ticci Toby, Jeff, Ben and maybe more
Completed

#15
Ticci Toby x reader Chocolate Waff...by TheKproxy
This girl is sweeter than a chocolate covered waffle with strawberries.

#16
Bloody Knives in My Leftoversby Gene
An x reader story. (Hoodie x Toby x Masky x Reader. Wow a poly fic omg)
When friends keep secrets it's usually for your own good, so what happens when those secrets are...

#17
Staticby ghostlyprogram
When Toby comes back from the dead suddenly Tenma is faced with a fierce brotherly rivalry and so he turns to you. All the while trouble is brewing in metro city.

#18
You met Ticci Toby at a party (mal...by C!nd¥
There were rumors about Ticci Toby. You thought he was popular, but it didn't go as you expected. He wasn't popular, he was well known. Then after awhile you both were g...
Completed

#20
Fallen Angel TobyxReaderby Lisa Shaffer
You must help the Creepypastas fight Zalgo, the world depends on it...