Tobyxreader Stories

Refine by tag:
tobyxreader
WpAddticcitoby
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddticcitobyxreader
WpAddcreepypastaxreader
WpAddtoby
WpAddxreader
WpAddtobyrogers
WpAddslenderman
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddmasky
WpAddproxy
WpAddhoodie
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddmaskyxreader
WpAddticci
WpAddhoodiexreader
WpAddjeffxreader
WpAddfanfiction
tobyxreader
WpAddticcitoby
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddticcitobyxreader
WpAddcreepypastaxreader
WpAddtoby
WpAddxreader
WpAddtobyrogers
WpAddslenderman
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddmasky
WpAddproxy
WpAddhoodie
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddmaskyxreader
WpAddticci
WpAddhoodiexreader
WpAddjeffxreader
WpAddfanfiction

111 Stories

  • Zombie and the Killer (ticci toby x reader ) by aynxoxo_
    aynxoxo_
    • WpView
      Reads 1,230
    • WpPart
      Parts 4
    (Y/N) has been toby Rogers best friend but when Toby becomes a proxy he forgets about her.(Y/N) becomes obsessed trying to find toby and gives up after 7 years of trying. When she was at her house a ticking boy comes to kill her. When toby ends her life a white faceless male brings her back to life but as a zombie ! Will Toby realized the zombie is (Y/N) or will you be lonely for life.
  • Please don't help me... (Ticci Toby x reader) by aperezlilly13
    aperezlilly13
    • WpView
      Reads 66
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    What is wrong with you? Why are you in love with a hatchet throwing killer? Why does hurting people feel so.. satisfying? And why does this guy GET it? You did something bad. Really bad. You know it's wrong and it feels wrong but.. something deep inside you likes is. Couldn't you just chew gum? Or have a better hobby? No, of course not! Instead your best hobby is murder, which is why now you're in this house full of psychos like you. Maybe that's why you've been hanging out with this one psycho and found him to be pretty interesting as you adjust to a new life as a malevolent entities killer. Disclaimer! All characters in this are not my own! Each creepypasta or proxy was made by someone else. This is just a story I'm writing. This is just fanfiction for me and anyone who wants to enjoy it! Some people forgot that. If this isn't your thing you are free to click away. Please no hate. This fic is a mix of the best aspects of the pastas or what I find interesting that works for the story narratively and character-wise. (I've been in this fandom so long!! Just got dragged back please send help ToT)
  • *TIC TIC* by Whodaman02
    Whodaman02
    • WpView
      Reads 42,189
    • WpPart
      Parts 9
    Ticci Toby x Reader
  • Your Mine... All Mine.. Yandere! Ticci TobyXreader by creepypast4life
    creepypast4life
    • WpView
      Reads 22
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    ⚠Cringe up ahead ⚠
  • Toby X Reader by DarkRaven358
    DarkRaven358
    • WpView
      Reads 53
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
    What happens when a man who can't feel any pain grows a passion for you. What will happen? Will you find your true love or fall for another killer?
  • Dark Tears With A Dark Past by duskyrain
    duskyrain
    • WpView
      Reads 2
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Storm Winters has been abused and raped since she was a little girl. She has voices in her head like Ticci Toby. She is abig fan of the creepy pastas. Will she find someone to love her? Read to find out
  • (Ticci Toby X Reader) Missing Love by LocalNonBinary1
    LocalNonBinary1
    • WpView
      Reads 10
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    A girl/guy or Non-Binary person, has no emotions, and was selected by Slenderman to become a Proxy. She gets a weird feeling when she/he/they see Toby. She/He/They started falling for him, will she/he/they be able to tell Toby how they feel or will it be to late?
  • Ticci toby x reader x ben drowned  by zennosuke
    zennosuke
    • WpView
      Reads 86
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    Y/n was going to a new school not knowing the fate they choosed when they walked threw those halls || it's the fate you choose || ||•Ticci toby x reader x ben drowned•|| ||They/them|
  • Creepypasta one-shots by CerberusLovesToWrite
    CerberusLovesToWrite
    • WpView
      Reads 106
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    legit the title- and uh- this is my first book! updates will be fat and few- I'm in school and have major writers block at times! please enjoy:D I own none of the characters in this book! All rights to them go to the original creators
  • Toby x FemReader His Little Mood Swinging Psycho by JustJadallee
    JustJadallee
    • WpView
      Reads 36
    • WpPart
      Parts 4
    What will happen when a mood swinging mortal, born with an inhuman ability, meets thee kind hearted, psychotic proxy, serial killer. Will she become just as crazy? (your name will be Taylor (l/n)) !!!threatening, cursing, blood!!!
  •  The Mysterious Visitor  Toby x reader by Shadoww0_olf763
    Shadoww0_olf763
    • WpView
      Reads 25
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    (The art on the cover is by shatteredankles on Instagram) Y/N is an girl she is out of her home town for her studie for art her dad is dead and her mum is abusive she has one older sibling she wanted to get out of her aduse house hold any way since her bad die there mum started to drink and aduse she and her older sibling When her older sibling left her mum started to abuse her more and started to drink more one day you me a boy with brown messy hair out side your house in the forest he than ends up being in...
  • Static by ghostlyprogram
    ghostlyprogram
    • WpView
      Reads 21,082
    • WpPart
      Parts 19
    When Toby comes back from the dead suddenly Tenma is faced with a fierce brotherly rivalry and so he turns to you. All the while trouble is brewing in metro city.
  • Ticci Toby X reader - Not So Bad by vincinious
    vincinious
    • WpView
      Reads 29
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
    Nothing.
  • If Things Were Different  by DrownedTrying
    DrownedTrying
    • WpView
      Reads 596
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    Twenty-one. The age everyone waits eagerly for, the day you discover who your soulmate and who your enemy are. Two different people, two different stories. Everything changes the night of your twenty-first birthday when something unexpected happens. Your luck has always been shit, but this time, it'd be bad enough to kill you. Considering, of course, they don't do it first. (Dark!Ticci Toby x Reader)
  • Together we're the perfect team (TobyXreader) by melody-the-otaku-
    melody-the-otaku-
    • WpView
      Reads 704
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
    New student Walking home and...
  • Ticci Toby X Reader  by TICCI123TOBY
    TICCI123TOBY
    • WpView
      Reads 17
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    You're name is teana(you can change it) and you are on a double date with Toby Ben and Sally
  • Ticci Toby likes you!!! by Bluerenneruth
    Bluerenneruth
    • WpView
      Reads 442
    • WpPart
      Parts 9
    (CreepyPasta) Ticci Toby loves you but you always thought he hated you so you'd yell at him but in near future he likes you and you like him but you don't know and he don't know. But they're only friends...for know. ^_^ (fluff ... Ish) probably smutty.
  • PRØXY LAW (tøby's law ;) by PrincessesPrOxY
    PrincessesPrOxY
    • WpView
      Reads 4
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Because some asked;)
  • Creepypasta High//CreepypastaxGoddessReader// [Discontinued] ((Im sorry)) by MIKACHUUZ
    MIKACHUUZ
    • WpView
      Reads 3,199
    • WpPart
      Parts 14
    At the slender mansion,Slenderman noticed that his proxies lack education like spelling,reading,grammar etc. So he enrolled them to a school where he studied called..... CREEPYPASTA HIGH Y/N a 19 year old is the student council president Her nickname was shadow since she wasn't really that sociable like always in the Shadows A cold council president but what happens when she meets the proxies? Will she open up to them? Read and find out what happens!