Tobyxreader Stories

Refine by tag:
tobyxreader
WpAddticcitoby
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddticcitobyxreader
WpAddcreepypastaxreader
WpAddtoby
WpAddxreader
WpAddslenderman
WpAddtobyrogers
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddmasky
WpAddproxy
WpAddhoodie
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddmaskyxreader
WpAddticci
WpAddhoodiexreader
WpAddjeffxreader
WpAddfanfiction
tobyxreader
WpAddticcitoby
WpAddcreepypasta
WpAddticcitobyxreader
WpAddcreepypastaxreader
WpAddtoby
WpAddxreader
WpAddslenderman
WpAddtobyrogers
WpAddjeffthekiller
WpAddmasky
WpAddproxy
WpAddhoodie
WpAddeyelessjack
WpAddbendrowned
WpAddmaskyxreader
WpAddticci
WpAddhoodiexreader
WpAddjeffxreader
WpAddfanfiction

110 Stories

  • Runaways - Ticci Toby by w4f3exe
    w4f3exe
    • WpView
      Reads 297
    • WpPart
      Parts 7
    Ticci Toby x fem!reader Toby was a criminal, a killer on the run. During his journey he stopped by your town, that's when he met you, a young, tired girl who needed an escape. Toby was infatuated with you, becoming progressively more obsessed, he stalked your daily life, following your every move. He resorted to keeping a safe distance, but slowly it became unbearable, he had to see you, touch you. And when he least expected it, you walked straight into his life. ★★★★★★★★ Art credits - @shatteredankles on Instagram. #1 in tobiasrogers - 1/7/25 #2 in tobyxreader - 1/7/25 #3 in tobyrogers - 1/7/25 #13 in ticcitoby - 1/7/25 #5 in ticcitoby - 1/10/25
  • ~Toby X Reader~ by 54321sasunaru
    54321sasunaru
    • WpView
      Reads 86
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Y/N is a 17 year old girl who has been suffering from depression.she is beaten by her father and her mother died 4 years ago in a car crash. Y/N is not only abused by her father but she is also bullied and beaten at school as well.one night her father had too much to drink and ended up almost killing her.she was quick and murded her father she took the knife and ran out of the house into the woods where she meets a boy named Toby and his friends hoodie and masky.what will happen when they get to know each other.
  • Ticci Toby likes you!!! by Bluerenneruth
    Bluerenneruth
    • WpView
      Reads 436
    • WpPart
      Parts 9
    (CreepyPasta) Ticci Toby loves you but you always thought he hated you so you'd yell at him but in near future he likes you and you like him but you don't know and he don't know. But they're only friends...for know. ^_^ (fluff ... Ish) probably smutty.
  • M.S.T.J.Reader by AvGreen808
    AvGreen808
    • WpView
      Reads 1,290
    • WpPart
      Parts 4
    masky x lost silver x reader x ticci toby x eyeless jack you are a girl that is the granddaughter of zlago the ruler of the underworld what happens when four boys fall in love with you you or the creepypasta ppl dont belong to me I am also writing this story on Quotev
  • Saved (ticci toby x reader) discontinued  by Ur_Jealous
    Ur_Jealous
    • WpView
      Reads 96,440
    • WpPart
      Parts 37
    Running, that's what you've done for a while now. You're abusive boyfriend is chasing you. Why, you ran away from him again. He's right behind you now and before he could grab you a blood curdling scream rang out.
  • Baby Where'd You Go... by Idk12345678912345667
    Idk12345678912345667
    • WpView
      Reads 23
    • WpPart
      Parts 4
    Hello so this is basically a Toby X reader fanfiction this is one of my first well this is my first fanfiction so it might be bad it might be cheesy. The story is about a girl/boy that really loves creepy pasta more than life itself meets with Toby Aaron Rodgers when there was a thunderstorm and a lot of to be continued s**t
  • Your always watching (Ticcitoby×FemaleReader) by Stary_Dreamz
    Stary_Dreamz
    • WpView
      Reads 86
    • WpPart
      Parts 6
    just a average Toby×Reader. ART NOT MINE!! If you like this trash check out my better written one 'Your Mine', and if you don't like this, still check it out. no beta, we simp like real emos. ⚠️This is not at all linked with 'Your Mine'! Just because they both have only one friend who happens to have the same name doesn't mean they are in any way the same person!⚠️ status: Discontinued
  • Ticci Toby x reader by i_hate_my_stepmom_
    i_hate_my_stepmom_
    • WpView
      Reads 6
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    hello people of the internet i am writing this book bc i have nothing better to do over the summer so here we are also this might be cringy to some people so if it is I'm sorry I'm only doing this bc I'm bored so it's not the best thing i have wrote before. ||| this story is about how a crazy teenager meets a killer and they fall in love... nah jk that's too boring but is about a crazy teenager named y/n m/n l/n meeting a killer named tobias erin "toby" rogers but goes by the name ticci toby or just toby. this story isn't about what you guys put toby as he is going to be a little more canon and i won't put in his stutters bc i'm lazy but i will make it clear that he does still have his stutters but i'm to lazy to actually write them bc it's a little hard to read like that and if you don't like it then to bad don't read it idc i'm only doing this bc i'm bored not to entertain people really but if you do like it then good for you.||| *|||* "why are you so weird" "I'm not that weird i'm not a serial killer unlike you, you're the weird one here" "..."
  • Midnight Break-In // Ticci Toby x Reader (Oneshot) by monocoin
    monocoin
    • WpView
      Reads 42
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    Wow another oneshot I made before I went to sleep at 3AM how exciting. A Ticci Toby from Creepypasta x reader oneshot.
  • Toby the Ant x Reader by Megabond098
    Megabond098
    • WpView
      Reads 19
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
    For those that have a crush on Toby here's the story for you!
  • Falling For a Pasta by ash_elum1204
    ash_elum1204
    • WpView
      Reads 64
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
    //AN. Hello hello hello! just wanted to make a Ticci Toby x Reader (Ticci Toby Imagines) book. This'll be updated regularly (I hope) uh well. enjoy!// You play as the lead role of the story. You were always adventurous and liked this wandering in the woods (near the house where the proxies live of course you didn't know that you smol lovely bean :3). One day you met HIM. This event caused your life to change. But how? for better? or for worst ...?
  • You're an idiot. I love that~ TOBY X READER by shadowsnowwy1
    shadowsnowwy1
    • WpView
      Reads 198
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    Says it all in da title.
  • Hide A body by suzuyaishiding
    suzuyaishiding
    • WpView
      Reads 13
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    cool mama cita come here
  • This Fever Dream: A Creepypasta x Reader Story  by Switchable_Waffle
    Switchable_Waffle
    • WpView
      Reads 119
    • WpPart
      Parts 3
    Y/N works as a doctor. However, their dreams are turned upside down when they are kidnapped by Jeff the Killer (per orders of Slenderman) and forced into a new lifestyle. Why were they kidnapped? They were stunned to learn that the main reason of their kidnapping was that: 1.) The proxies needed a more skilled doctor than EJ and 2.) They also needed a full time maid as the house gets too dirty too quickly for Slenderman's liking. So hence the reason you are there. However, strange things keep happening to you hence your current question: Why do you keep having serious deja vu?
  • Bloody Love by vampyboyf
    vampyboyf
    • WpView
      Reads 3,975
    • WpPart
      Parts 33
    ⚠️THIS IS MY FIRST WORK EVER IT IS SO OLD I WAS LIKE FIFTEEN AND ANGSTY WRITING THIS SO IT SUCKS. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK IT HAS MATURE THEMES AND WILL GO THROUGH VERY HEAVY EDITING AND MAYBE JUST MAYBE FINISHED⚠️ You are Y/N and you are happy with all of the little things that you have and are happy with your best friend Jaz. Until some events happen and change the once happy ray of sunshine to a living nightmare. You keep to yourself and is always trying to make people happy but now you only care about the ones you have lost. But soon you get taken to the Slender Mansion to live with the other pastas. Will this truly be best for you? This is a Jeff the killer X reader X Ticci Toby book so enjoy
  • The Numb Boy by Ticci_Tim
    Ticci_Tim
    • WpView
      Reads 26
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    You've moved around a lot ever since you were little, well now you finally get the chance to make and keep friend, maybe even pursue a boyfriend, however the boy your interested in is a strange one. With the same condition as you.
  • Fallen Angel TobyxReader by LisaShaffer763
    LisaShaffer763
    • WpView
      Reads 30
    • WpPart
      Parts 2
    You must help the Creepypastas fight Zalgo, the world depends on it...
  • A Side of Waffles Please {Completed} by Greekblood
    Greekblood
    • WpView
      Reads 2,120
    • WpPart
      Parts 5
    This is a Toby x reader. This is a sequel to Bloody Knives, a Jeff x reader. Thank you all who read my first fanfic.
  • Ticci Toby X Reader by Midoriya_is_best_boi
    Midoriya_is_best_boi
    • WpView
      Reads 3
    • WpPart
      Parts 1
  • Ticci Toby x Reader by xHxffungslose
    xHxffungslose
    • WpView
      Reads 150
    • WpPart
      Parts 4
    You are a normal 17-year-old girl with a normal and boring life. But one day, someone new comes into your class. With that, your whole life changes.