Tobyxreader Stories

What is wrong with you? Why are you in love with a hatchet throwing killer? Why does hurting people feel so.. satisfying? And why does this guy GET it? You did something bad. Really bad. You know it's wrong and it feels wrong but.. something deep inside you likes is. Couldn't you just chew gum? Or have a better hobby? No, of course not! Instead your best hobby is murder, which is why now you're in this house full of psychos like you. Maybe that's why you've been hanging out with this one psycho and found him to be pretty interesting as you adjust to a new life as a malevolent entities killer. Disclaimer! All characters in this are not my own! Each creepypasta or proxy was made by someone else. This is just a story I'm writing. This is just fanfiction for me and anyone who wants to enjoy it! Some people forgot that. If this isn't your thing you are free to click away. Please no hate. This fic is a mix of the best aspects of the pastas or what I find interesting that works for the story narratively and character-wise. (I've been in this fandom so long!! Just got dragged back please send help ToT)

Your a high school girl you have a pet wolf named Keilo and you become friends with all the pastas' including ones you didn't know existed. This story has OCs' and your normal pastas and involves a lot of bad language and some sexual scenes. Reader discretion is advised Hope you enjoy!! ~KAIA OUT!!! 🦄

//AN. Hello hello hello! just wanted to make a Ticci Toby x Reader (Ticci Toby Imagines) book. This'll be updated regularly (I hope) uh well. enjoy!// You play as the lead role of the story. You were always adventurous and liked this wandering in the woods (near the house where the proxies live of course you didn't know that you smol lovely bean :3). One day you met HIM. This event caused your life to change. But how? for better? or for worst ...?

Y/N works as a doctor. However, their dreams are turned upside down when they are kidnapped by Jeff the Killer (per orders of Slenderman) and forced into a new lifestyle. Why were they kidnapped? They were stunned to learn that the main reason of their kidnapping was that: 1.) The proxies needed a more skilled doctor than EJ and 2.) They also needed a full time maid as the house gets too dirty too quickly for Slenderman's liking. So hence the reason you are there. However, strange things keep happening to you hence your current question: Why do you keep having serious deja vu?

"You promised you won't leave me, that you'll always be by my side! Don't you remember?!" "No..." - Started: 071418 Ended: 061419 11.9K words Highest Rankings: #72 in shortstory (190k+ stories) #756 in fanfiction (850k+ stories) #65 in creepypasta (61k+ stories) #10 in ticcitoby (7k+ stories) #9 in ticcitobyxreader (290+ stories) #3 in readerxcreepypasta (280+ stories) #2 in tobyxreader (90+ stories)

Because some asked;)

The story will include (hopefully I can't guaretee cause I might get lazy and give up on this story) EJ, Ticci Toby, Jeff, Ben and maybe more

here we are again lol and you can tell me some story stuff as long as its not smut im good

I'm lazy so don't expect much from me but I'll try to write this story as often as I can. Thanks @Jaschicken for the cover

Toby finds you in a forest crying for help. What are you doing there? Why is he so interested in you all of a sudden? Is he blushing?

hello tobsters this is my first book.

This is the story of the Mad Hatter's daughter and how she becomes a creepypasta. This is a Ticci Toby x Reader

New student Walking home and...

A girl/guy or Non-Binary person, has no emotions, and was selected by Slenderman to become a Proxy. She gets a weird feeling when she/he/they see Toby. She/He/They started falling for him, will she/he/they be able to tell Toby how they feel or will it be to late?

Well this is my first story so please don't hate on it. I probably won't get any reads or anything but if someone does actually find it well thanks!

(CreepyPasta) Ticci Toby loves you but you always thought he hated you so you'd yell at him but in near future he likes you and you like him but you don't know and he don't know. But they're only friends...for know. ^_^ (fluff ... Ish) probably smutty.

A quiet walk in the woods, that'll settle your crazy imagination. 'There is no guy with goggles stalking you, there is no guy with a mask stalking you!' Suddenly your face to face with this man with cracked orange goggles, wrecked mouth mask and a hoodie sweater with stomach quenching blood stains. He then grabs you and- (Read the story to find out)

(The art on the cover is by shatteredankles on Instagram) Y/N is an girl she is out of her home town for her studie for art her dad is dead and her mum is abusive she has one older sibling she wanted to get out of her aduse house hold any way since her bad die there mum started to drink and aduse she and her older sibling When her older sibling left her mum started to abuse her more and started to drink more one day you me a boy with brown messy hair out side your house in the forest he than ends up being in...

"I told you the night you tried to kill me; he's not your God." Sequel to An Eye For An Eye. Years after The Subordinate is closed, Y/N attempts to rebuild her life and recover from her short-lived romance with Toby. He's a changed man since becoming a proxy, with memory loss and lust for murder. Her heart still longs for him even years later. Will their relationship ever be repaired? The Slenderman is keeping an eye on them. TW: Mature themes!