This story is taken from Choi Mingi/Ren's POV. "You are always shines like a star in the sky. Your smile can makes everyone easily falling in love with you. The moment when I saw you there without us, I finally realized that my place is not beside you anymore, because you have Minhyun by your side. But I still hope someday you will realize that I love you so much, JR." Author Notes: This is the first time i write using Ren's full POV, which explain why I'm using 'you' to refer to JR. Also i write their names using the profile from Produce 101, since actually this story is made when i'm stressed out because of that Produce 101 show. i really hope that they will succeed on Produce 101 though. Keep Support NU'EST and happy anniversary NU'EST! (ps: this story also made for NU'EST anniversary)