Joanne Cato, better known as Jo, has just about everything. The perfect college, the perfect best friend, and of course, the perfect boyfriend. The only thing she doesn't have is Lila Brays acting talents, which always end up giving her the leads in every play, musical, and production. But when Jo finally lands the lead for her favorite musical, "Heathers", she's ecstatic until she realizes she should be careful for what she wishes for.