He's Expecting You

Jonathan, he was the heart breaker of his school, breaking both male and female hearts at unexpected times in the relationship. He was the rebel, who happened to be interested in cults. People thought he was a god. He was always confident that he would come out on top, until he was kidnapped. His father hadn't seen Jonathan for a few months and was starting to worry. So, he did what any right minded human would do and called the police to file a missing person report. They never found him, so no one knows his story, but Jonathan knows.
(By the way, I'll be trying to read all of the comments!)