What if you found out that your ultimate crush has an identical twin brother? Corrie Holt, a bubbly 16 year old, a music lover and an excellent student, has an ultimate crush on Finn Sheffrey. She hadn't seen him for two years since he moved away. Shockingly, on her first day back to school, she met Finn's twin brother, Matt Sheffrey who is a total opposite of Finn. He is a nerd unlike the jock, popular, bad boy type, Finn. But he is just as gorgeous as Finn without the black rimmed glasses and what seemed to be grandpa's hand-me-down clothes. Trapped between two differing guys with identical charming and handsome faces, Corrie needs to choose between the two of them before things go haywire. Will she choose the innocent, kind and studious, Matt or the popular, bad boy, Finn?