The Consequences

Reads 571
Votes 23
Parts 9
Time 23m

Reads 571
Votes 23
Parts 9
Time 23m

Benny joins the Creepypasta family in the Slender Mansion and has 4 boys that like her: Ben, Jeff, E.J and Ticci Toby. Benny likes all four of them, but can't choose who to pick.All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

9 parts

Content Guidelines

You may also like

this is a romantic/horror story a bout a tragic love and a new being . this story also include Jeff , Ben,sally,slender man ,Toby And of course Eyeless jack. hope you enjoy stay creepy.

Painful Love-(Ticcimask fan fiction) by TicciToby_Lover

When the new proxy, Toby, comes to live at the Slender mansion, Masky is a little happy, but still doesn't like the idea that he has to watch over him. But what happens when Toby gets into some trouble that he didn't even cause. In this story Toby's life was is worse than any other pasta, (just an FWI) also, I made Toby have a form of autism that makes it so he's very crazy and doesn't like being touched a lot. A few curses here and there. Plus some rape. Trigger warning ⚠️

Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios (Complete) by Tinypotato06

So..I am in love with creepypastas and I thought why not write a book..so here you go this will involve Slenderman Jeff the killer Ben drowned Hoodie Masky Ticci Toby Offenderman Eyeless Jack Laughing Jack Sorry if this is cringe, I wrote it when I was 12

Deep Secret (Ben Drowned x Ticci Toby) by flowerprince4

Ben Drowned was the new Creepypasta that moved into the mansion. He meets everyone in the mansion but there's one of them that he feels he really connects to,they end up as roommates for some time causing them to become closer but Ben starts to develop feelings for Toby but his fear of being rejected makes him start becoming more distant with his best friend until he finally breaks..

On The Edge Of Desire (Ticci Toby) by K9Rouge

(Ticci Toby x Reader)

My Dad's Are Gay[Complete] by bisexual_miki20

A little girl's dad's are gay. she is a creepypasta, due to be separated from her brother ticci toby. she got separated from him after he killed their parents. what happens when she sees him again and he sees her parents are jeff and ben? Word Count: Between 18k-19k words

Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby by 1800-WERE-FCKING-GAY

He killed his dad, found a new home, finally settled in, even made some new friends. What else? Oh yeah, and watched his crush get brutally murdered and sacrificed by a cult.

Needus Deletus Lmao (Ticcimask) by FoxyZeGeekGamer

There's a new pasta in the famous Slender mansion. Tobias Erin Rogers. Otherwise known as the infamous Ticci Toby. He's the newest pasta and the newest proxy. Masky has feelings towards the small boy. Will Toby return the feelings? Or will he deny the feelings? Read this to find out! (I'm really sorry if it's cringy. Most of my stories are XD)

The Loser (Creepypasta x reader) -DISCONTINUED- by Painted_Happy

Her dad brings her to a house of strange people, soon to be her friends. He leaves after a while and finds a new occupation. How unfortunate for her for what happens next.

Ticci-Toby X Female Reader (Has Some Triggering Themes) (English Version) by Alcuin_Slender

You have abusive foster parents and you get taken into the slender mansion and have many fun adventures with the pastas, even a little romance involved...

I See you

this is a romantic/horror story a bout a tragic love and a new being . this story also include Jeff , Ben,sally,slender man ,Toby And of course Eyeless jack. hope you enjoy stay creepy.

More details