The small town of Hackensaw, Louisiana seems to attract drifters-or lonely people searching for, craving love. Several middle aged men have gone missing, and Sam and Dean go to investigate. After a long day with no clues, and nothing else to do, Dean finds himself alone at a bar, when he meets a gorgeous, young woman named Nikki who says she can hopefully help them find the killer. But soon after they start talking, Dean finds himself falling in love. When he doesn't return to their hotel room one morning, and they're not at Nikki's apartment either, Sam find that he and Nikki have disappeared. He immediately goes off to investigate, when he, too goes missing.