Gina Thompkins has been in the closet for the past ten years. At the age of 16, she came to the realization she was a lesbian after a drunken kiss with a random girl during a game of spin the bottle. Now at the age of 26, she still hasn't found the right girl for her. Tired of her friends ridiculing her for being a closeted virgin, she decides to lose her virginity. Now the problem is having to decide between two very different girls.