The Two Sins [A Creepypasta Love Story] - Toby - Wattpad

The Two Sins [A Creepypasta Love Story]

Reads 89
Votes 6
Parts 10
Time 57m

Reads 89
Votes 6
Parts 10
Time 57m

Mature

clockwork creepypasta creepypastafanfiction demons fanfiction fluff hoodie incubus janethekiller jeffthekiller lemon lime masky ocs romance slenderman succubus ticcitoby zalgo

I'm bad at descriptions, but this is about an Incubus and a girl who is an unknown species of demon who find themselves at Slender's mansion as proxies. (Like I said, I suck at descriptions). 

Toby the Sin belongs to me.
Ender the Sin, Sarah the Stalker, Rogue, Dollhouse, Victor, Mannquin and her other OCs that happen to be in this story, belong to @Trappedinmyheadx

The cover was also made by @Trappedinmyheadx, she's a doll go check her out!All Rights Reserved

clockwork creepypasta creepypastafanfiction demons fanfiction fluff hoodie incubus janethekiller jeffthekiller lemon lime masky ocs romance slenderman succubus ticcitoby zalgo

Table of contents

10 parts

Sign up to add The Two Sins [A Creepypasta Love Story] to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Where the wolves go, ravens follow (Creepypasta) by Jewel_Evelyn

I (poorly) edited the cover lol ajkfdjacnjecgb Written in Toby's p.o.v unless stated otherwise. In this version most of the Creepypasta characters live together. Personal fanon versions of the characters. I apologize if they seem out of character! I like experimenting with my own interpretations of them. I have nothing against the originals and I also adore other people's versions of these characters! Contains shipping!!! Everything's more fast paced in this fanfic (at least I tried),,, If you don't like my story or my versions of the characters then that's totally okay, I don't mind! Just please don't give me hate comments or threatening messages. AU where Creepypasta and Marble Hornets mix and Proxies work for the Slenderman. Contains violence! (fighting, blood etc. standard Creepypasta stuff) I am aware that it's cringe EEk🥲 This is not referring to real people!!!! These characters don't belong to me!!

Slenderman - Three Proxies by Multi-FandomFangirl2

This is a story about Slenderman and him talking about his three proxies; Masky, Hoodie, and Ticci Toby. Masky: Timothy Sutton grew up in a mental health asylym ever since he was a small child. He's been seeing things ever since. But now, the things he sees seem so real. Then, something happens that'll change his life forever. Hoodie: Ever since his bestest friend Tim disappeared, Brian has been looking for him and wondering where he has gone. Just when he thinks that Tim is dead, Brian receives a strange letter in the mail only to realize that it was from Tim. What shocking secrets will he find out about Tim and where he's been all along? Ticci Toby: Toby Rogers is an average 16 year old high schooler. Although, he can't feel pain and he twitches every once and awhile. Until one day, he and his older sister get into a car crash, killing her and leaving him with minor injuries and a broken arm. He slowly begins to lose his mind and he starts seeing a tall figure outside of his window. Where will fate leave Toby Rogers?

Creepypasta One-Shots by urlocal_civil1

!!On Hiatus!! This is for all you horny Creepypasta lovers. Enjoy. Also, I will allow gay and lesbian smuts, they don't have to be straight smuts. Edit: This is now a one-shot. Request what you like. Disclaimer! I do not own the Creepypasta Fandom, the characters belong to it's creators and/or themselves.

I Think I Love You by starrykid19

From burning his house down, to being taken in by a faceless eldritch creature. Toby has now become curious about a certain mask wearing man. He knows just the way to get closer to him, but he realizes this might be more than he bargained for. Warning for: Gore, medical descriptions/situations, and slight homophobia. Mansion AU! art by: yasmimkilleruwu on tumblr (Rewriting! Slight OOC Toby, personal headcanons ensue. Comments and votes appreciated!)

What Lies UnderNeath by Princesspastel8

○•SEQUEL TO "Secret Desire"•○ Everything isn't how it seems. This world is cold, full of cruel people, and the supernatural. Murders, Thieves, Rapist, Witches, Demons, Angels. Luna & Toby fall into that category. As do Iris & Hoodie Added with Taylor & Masky. Things are fairly normal between the top trio proxies. Going on missions, succeeding without fail, then continue to live their lives within the mansion. But things become unusual the moment Toby is assigned to take down one of Zalgo's top workers, The Blue Witch- Luna. Unfortunately, Toby fails- miserably. But after encountering her once, Toby can't seem to erase her from his mind. After some time he goes to see her, try to attack her again- but fails. A year later, Slenderman request for Toby to try again- this time involving Masky & Hoodie. They still fail, and have many casualties. Unfortunately, all worlds are turned upside down thanks to these faithful Encounters. Better for some, but worse for others. "Do you believe in Red string soulmates? People that are tied together for all of eternity?" "No. a fate like that s-seems to sound." She smiles, looking at him with glowing blue eyes. "That's why you can't forget about me Toby, and that's why I can't forget you either. We're tied together, for all of eternity. I'm sorry the world decided to fate me with you.....unfortunately things are going to get worse from here." "what do you m-mean?" "You'll see. Magic has no limitations." 🔞= smut chapters. WARNING: this book is HIGHLY TRIGGERING! This book contains themes such as ra*e, SA, drug use, drug abuse, mental- physical- emotional- verbal abuse, gore, self harm, extreme violence. VIEWERS DISCRETION IS ADVISED!!!!! - I do not own any pictures used in this book nor the characters(only Iris, Taylor, Luna, & Eboni)

Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} by mortuusrising

{C O M P L E T E D} -- An orphan girl, (y/n) (l/n) an abused and bullied girl with depression. Her life changes when she is taken to become the newest proxy, and meets the proxies. Read to find out what happens next! -- Cover by: @OliverTheHoodini -- *contains: mature language, potential triggers, abuse, and depression. (so far)* -- This is a crossover universe/alternate universe where the events of marble hornets did happen but Hoodie never died and instead of Tim (Masky) running away from the law, they both went with The operator. The operator will be Slenderman not a different entity in this story -- I am very aware that Masky and Hoodie aren't creepypasta characters, and that they have never and will never be in anyway connected to creepypasta. -- Masky and hoodie belong to THAC Ticci-Toby belongs to Kastoway (even though Kastoway doesn't care anymore) -- sorry for such a long description. But, enjoy!

The Siren Sisters (A Creepypasta Fanfic) by May5696

They once had a dream. All they wanted to do was sing. But that dream was cut short when their lives were taken from them. Now all they want is revenge. This is the story of three sisters on a quest for power. Everything was going great. They escaped the police, took refuge at a bar, had all the men swooning for them. But all of that changes when a mysterious stranger with a carved smile appears. Will these sisters make new allies? Or new enemies? WARNING: Some of the content in this story may be a bit mature for younger readers. I do not own any of the songs used in this story and I do not own any of the Creepypasta characters except my OC's.

Bittersweet | Ticci Toby by sirin_writes

◤━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━◥ Bittersweet /ˈbɪt̬.ɚˌswiːt/ (adj.) "containing a mixture of happiness and sadness" ◣━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━◢ A series of unfortunate events determine you to want to pluck a certain goggled male's eyes out. He seems to enjoy the dynamic between the two of you. Do you? If you're looking for one of those classic old fashion creepypasta fanfics with a disgusting amount of swearing, but with no cringe slendermansion, look no further this is it. TW: MAJOR gore and blood warning, swearing, stalking, murder, lots of death, angst, mental illness, lots of bad decisions 🙏 (Female!ReaderxYandere! Ticci Toby) enemies to lovers Slenderverse AU

¤The Mansion Maid¤ by grrr__idek

《𝑺𝒑𝒐𝒐𝒌𝒚 𝒏𝒐𝒐𝒅𝒍𝒆𝒔》 '𝔾𝕖𝕥 𝕤𝕞𝕒𝕤𝕙𝕖𝕕 𝕎𝕙𝕒𝕥.' After getting hacked, you were invited to some random group chat filled with killers and stuff. You got kidnapped and made to do the house chores. 𝟓𝐔𝐂𝐊𝟓 𝟕𝟎 𝟖𝟑 𝐘𝟎𝐔 𝟏𝟎𝟏. Anyways, they eat some contaminated food and become all weird and you have to deal with their tomfoolery (Female! reader x Creepypastas) (Maybe yandere idk) (A/N) I've been waiting ages to publish this book so it might be shit I'm fine with criticism constructive or not credits for the cover https://www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/737534876496867960/

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] by cinnabunny08

I'm no longer working on this story. Truth be told, I don't like it. I kept telling myself that once I got it started I'd sort of warm up to it, but at this point I've given up on it. I have no motivation nor desire to continue it. I do, however, have other CreepyPasta-related story ideas. Stay tuned for those. <3

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Where the wolves go, ravens follow (Creepypasta) cover

Slenderman - Three Proxies cover

Creepypasta One-Shots cover

I Think I Love You cover

What Lies UnderNeath cover

Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} cover

The Siren Sisters (A Creepypasta Fanfic) cover

Bittersweet | Ticci Toby cover

¤The Mansion Maid¤ cover

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] cover

Where the wolves go, ravens follow (Creepypasta)

I (poorly) edited the cover lol ajkfdjacnjecgb Written in Toby's p.o.v unless stated otherwise. In this version most of the Creepypasta characters live together. Personal fanon versions of the characters. I apologize if they seem out of character! I like experimenting with my own interpretations of them. I have nothing against the originals and I also adore other people's versions of these characters! Contains shipping!!! Everything's more fast paced in this fanfic (at least I tried),,, If you don't like my story or my versions of the characters then that's totally okay, I don't mind! Just please don't give me hate comments or threatening messages. AU where Creepypasta and Marble Hornets mix and Proxies work for the Slenderman. Contains violence! (fighting, blood etc. standard Creepypasta stuff) I am aware that it's cringe EEk🥲 This is not referring to real people!!!! These characters don't belong to me!!