Ali and Lisa had been best friends since the first grade, which meant they had been through the good and bad times together including the accident that happened Sophomore year. Now, it was senior year and not only were they both broken, but they couldn't even turn to each other. When Lisa's boyfriend Paul dumps her in front of all of their friends after his two week absence, then continues to ask Ali out immediately after, Lisa is NOT happy. She comes up with Plan Heartbreak, it was simple Ali was to make Paul fall for her then break his heart. Paul was falling for Ali at a rate neither of them expected, whenever Ali's past shows up in the form of twin brothers. One alive ranting insanely about how he believes that his twin is not dead, and one dead that still haunts all of Ali's memories. Ali soon realizes that Paul may be the only one who can actually help her find out the truth of what happened in that accident, but when she does find out the truth will it not even matter?