Secretly, Me {FNAF - Plushtrap X Nightmare} - SocietiesSarcasm

$Story cover for Secretly, Me {FNAF - Plushtrap X Nightmare} by CrazyMofo_x3$

Secretly, Me {FNAF - Plushtrap X Nightmare}

Reads 1,333
Votes 46
Parts 3
Time 16m

Reads 1,333
Votes 46
Parts 3
Time 16m

five fivenightsatfreddys fnaf gay nightmare plush plushmare plushtrap yaoi

Being famous online was cool and all, but secretly hating yourself? That just made things worse. No one knew why Plush began doing what he did at his young age but Nightmare's about to find out.All Rights Reserved

five fivenightsatfreddys fnaf gay nightmare plush plushmare plushtrap yaoi

Table of contents

3 parts

#19plushtrap

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Just My Boss... {Nightmare X Nightmare Fredbear} by agaywriterr

In a house full of nightmares, Nightmare the leader doesn't really seem to like much people. While Nightmare Fredbear likes to talk to everyone. The other nightmares are just there and like to hang out with everyone... Some to say they really don't Nightmare to be their leader but they know that he's strong. Nightmare also is always wearing a bandana over his eyes... I wonder why Nightmare Fredbear soon finds out he has fallen for his boss. Nightmare Fredbear doesn't want Nightmare to know about this feelings... But... That doesn't work out...

Scotty was seven years old, and about to turn eight. He was a very shy little boy, with no real friends. The only "friends" he had were his plush toys, given to him by his father. His father, Scott Sr., worked at a family restaurant called Fredbear's Family Diner. Scotty hated that place. The animatronics they used freaked him out. What it was about the plushies that made them likeable, even though he hates the place, he does not know. Because of work, Scotty's father was never home, and Scotty's brother wasn't so nice. although everyone knew all of this would make Scotty sad, no one knew what the true extent of his torture would become... Based on the video game "Five Nights At Freddy's 4" created by Scott Cawthon. Check out the official theme song, "Home" by NateWantsToBattle! Music Video: https://youtu.be/fLlqYn2LIcg (links to purchase in video description)

Complete Nightmare has a hard time trusting people due to what has happen in his life. Soon he remeets his friends from High School and yet again gets very close to Nightmare Fredbear again. But will his happiness stay? Or will "they" find them? Bleh Bleh read now

I wrote this when I was, like, twelve. I deeply apologize for this monstrosity, now that I'm eighteen.

𝐘𝐨𝐮 𝐀𝐧𝐝 𝐈 | 𝐌𝐢𝐜𝐡𝐚𝐞𝐥 𝐀𝐟𝐭𝐨𝐧 by llistenbeforeigo

You are a 15 year old girl who's dad died when you were 7. Your mom became crazy because of that and had to get taken away. She then moved in with her aunt for some time. Then her aunt got old and went to a shelter. You had to live on your own so you had to find a job, there you meet someone unexpected. - Started: March 8, 2022 Ended: September 30, 2022 This isn't the normal fnaf, So none of the Aftons are dead and the Aftons all have a healthy relationship (even William and Michael, But of course, they still fight because lots of families fight O.o) [Warning: There won't be much blood, But I will put a warning for anything that could trigger people] OLD TITLES (in order : oldest to newest) You and I ~ Michael Afton x Reader

Happier and Prettier - a DNF story by killmedreamy

After Dream finds a new boyfriend, George can't help but feel inferior in every possible way. Will jealousy consume him? Or will Dream recognise his friends infatuation over him before it's too late? (hello people from tiktok)

Breaking Point {Fronnie} by AwkwardShippings

{Warnings: Gore, Sexual Content, Swearing} Both found eachother somehow. In the twisted place they now we're forced to call home, they'll find out just how much mysteries there are here. They'll encounter mysterious people who look like them, and a little boy who seems harmless but will actually play a manipulative part on their relationship. Will they break or will they find a way to figure it out?

Accident (Yandere Toy Freddy x Taken Reader) by HammerOfRage

Hey. It's okay. Accidents happen. I didn't mean to, I swear.

Trust Issues(Nightmare x NightmareFredbear) by Nova_The_WolfOG

Fredbear has fallen for his boss Nightmare, but doesn't know how to tell him... The worst part is that he still doesn't trust Fred and the others just yet... But he's going to change that! 'The Warnings' gay and straight ships Bullying Self Harm OCS Male Pregnacy Intersex Male 'Ships inculded in this story(Main ones)' Nightmare Fronnie Nightmare Foxica Nightmare Springle(I guess) Fredmare/Nightbear

About A Girl [Michael Afton x Reader] by xqamora

I've always hated the thought of moving somewhere else. I left everything behind. My friends, my boyfriend and my memories. Mom said it was a good idea to restart my life and think about better choices. Maybe it won't be so bad. Maybe I could finally get my life started here. Hurricane, Utah here I come. It's the year 1983 and Y/N moves to a new town called Hurricane, Utah. Moving in somewhere new and unfamiliar with meant new friends, new drama, and falling in love. Michael Afton. Tough on the outside but he held a very special place for y/n in his heart. For she was the first girl to not leave his side. [ Contains Trigger Warnings Art Credit to @Mayhemmi ]

Just My Boss... {Nightmare X Nightmare Fredbear}

In a house full of nightmares, Nightmare the leader doesn't really seem to like much people. While Nightmare Fredbear likes to talk to everyone. The other nightmares are just there and like to hang out with everyone... Some to say they really don't Nightmare to be their leader but they know that he's strong. Nightmare also is always wearing a bandana over his eyes... I wonder why Nightmare Fredbear soon finds out he has fallen for his boss. Nightmare Fredbear doesn't want Nightmare to know about this feelings... But... That doesn't work out...

More details