Zach Andrews is not your average 16 year old jock. He doesn't do drugs, he doesn't smoke, he doesn't throw wild parties, he doesn't sleep with random girls, he doesn't sneak out, he doesn't curse or swear and he's certainly not a bad boy. Being homeschooled all his life, there's a lot of things he doesn't know, moving from big city Chicago to small town Sallyville offers him an opportunity he never had; a public school. Nathaniel Mann is the strange kid that gets all the medals for schoolwork and has a weird habit of carrying all his books home for the weekend. He certainly has more than enough problems to sink a 15 year old, with a blind mother to take care of and a house to maintain, he has no time for hanky-pankies. Suddenly, there's a friend to help Nate, the world isn't quite on his shoulders and he is not sinking anymore. Life is going fine for everyone. Not so fast though, throw in a beach party, some drunken confessions, never-have-i-evers, near death experiences and don't forget our beloved truth or dares. There you go, the perfect recipe for disaster. Nothing ever goes wrong in the quaint little town of Sallyville, nothing except everything.