Love At First Sight

Andy never thought she'll find her first love at a party. She never even knew how it felt to be 'In love'. Where you suppose to feel butterflies in your stomach when your around them? Where you suppose to feel goose bumps coming when they touched your skin? 
Shane made Andy feel all the ways a person would feel if they were in love. 

They began to have something. A connection with each other. But, when Shane's ex-girlfriend Samantha comes back from California, everything changes. Samantha tries to take Shane away from Andy.

Which girl is Shane going to choose? He likes Andy, because she doesn't ask for things to be bought for her. He feels like he could tell her anything and everything. Andy makes Shane feel as right. He could be himself around her. Shane feels as if there's nothing else going on in the world when he's with her.

He also still has some feelings for his ex, Samantha. Who is prettier, and skinner than Andy. But, the way He feels when he's with Andy, aren't the same with Samantha. She makes him feel as if he isn't important. She always likes to talk about herself. 
Samantha says shes different now, she changed since last summer. 
She begins to always be with Shane, and making sure he doesnt talk to her, or hang out with her. 

Andy gets jealous. Very jealous. She doesn't know what to do. She's going to try to show him she's the one for him.

Which girl would Shane choose?