Black Fairy

What if Natsu never fell in love with Lucy? What if, instead, she loved him, never admitted it, Natsu loved another girl, and Juvia's still obsessed with Gray, but he and Natsu's girlfriend grew up together, a sibling like bond between them. Erza and Jellal finally got together, but things will only go uphill from here. Something Soul never admitted to Maka, he wasn't alone. He has a sister, Psyche, who goes by the name Sphinx due to her intelligence as a secret agent by Lord Death himself. Why was it such a big secret? Because She's a witch. After Fairy Tail split up, Psyche having been a member for only a few days, she found Natsu unconscious after a fight with Gajeel; her target. Taking him in, things quickly progress, that is until a disaster strikes for the third year in a row at the newly opened Grand Magic Games.
*This is a parallel to Black Lightning and uses characters from children of justice
**DON'T HATE FOR BREAKING UP NALU IT WAD JUST A RANDOM IDEA I WANTED TO TRY
I ALWAYS TRY TO RELATE MT CHARACTER TO THE GUILD AND I WANTED A CHANGE FROM GRAY AND I ALREADY HAVE ONE WITH LAXUS