Dawn over Dusk~The Creature's/TFU FF

Alice Ronford was only sixteen when she moved from her quiet hometown in Oklahoma. Her mother said that it would be best to forget her father, but Alice knew better. She knew the real reason that her mother wanted to move, but she paid her no mind.
Once they get to their new home, in Colorado, Alice rarely see's her mother; who is always working her job. Alicia must attend a public school, in a small neighborhood; but what happens when she becomes a victim of someone's cruel game?
Kevin McFarlane, the schools all-star and womanizer, has his eyes set on Alice; who is new meat in his territory. He plans to get up close to her, and make her crumble. What happens when she see's right through his lies? And what happens when he falls hard for her?
Aleks Marshant, the school's flirt, also has his eyes on Alice. Despite having a girlfriend; Tiffany, He begins to fall for her. He tries his best to win her over, but never successfully gets an answer. What happens when he does receive an answer?

Which one will be most successful at winning her over? Which will fail?