Witch Pie?
DarkTwistedSisters
  • Reads 104
  • Votes 15
  • Parts 15
  • Time 3h 52m
  • Reads 104
  • Votes 15
  • Parts 15
  • Time 3h 52m
DarkTwistedSisters
Complete, First published Jul 11, 2017
Mature
badjujubakersbobbybrothersconfrontationfanfictionfriendshuntersmiscommunicationofcx2ratedmature4laterstoriesseriessisterssupernaturalthesecretisoutwattys2017weownnothingbutplotandofcswhereisjohnwinchesters
Meet Mae and Lilly, two girls who couldn't be more different who end up meeting Dean and Sam under some very incriminating circumstances. Assumptions are made. Pie is eaten. John is still missing and Bobby's no where to be found. Are these girls really witches? Or is there more happening than meets the eye? BOOK 1 of our Bakers, Hunters and Pie series!
All Rights Reserved
badjujubakersbobbybrothersconfrontationfanfictionfriendshuntersmiscommunicationofcx2ratedmature4laterstoriesseriessisterssupernaturalthesecretisoutwattys2017weownnothingbutplotandofcswhereisjohnwinchesters
Table of contents

15 parts

Sign up to add Witch Pie? to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Cursed Pie? by DarkTwistedSisters
38 parts Complete Mature
Book 3: Dean and Sam return to Sioux Falls after they bring down Azazel, to keep a promise made in haste. They still have no idea what is going on with Lilly, the girl who incites rage and her sister who seems to know how they're feeling before they do. Can they help the bakers that have inexplicably become apart of their family? Or will they end up scaring them off with the darkness that comes with the life of hunting? It's been nearly a year since Lilly and Mae have seen the hunters but what will happen when they invite the brothers to stay? Besides Bobby throwing a fit of course... How will the girls handle the hunters and the life they lead when it's right in their face? Will they actually be able to accept it? Or will they run? Deceit and manipulation runs deep in this installment. Mae can tell the brothers are lying and even Lilly has her own suspicions, but they aren't the only ones keeping secrets... What will happen when the truth finally bubbles to the surface? Will the tension between Lilly and Dean finally break? Will the romance between Sam and Mae ever spark? Or will the lies douse the flame before it even gets a chance to light?
Winchester Siblings: Capture (Book 1) (A Supernatural Series) by DaunyelS80
18 parts Complete
Book 1 of the Winchester Siblings series. What happens when the Winchester boys find out that not only evil is after them, but that they have a sister they knew of? Will the end come at last? Created 08 April 2006 Completed 08 April 2006 Updated 22 April 2023
The Sisters (A Sam Winhester & Dean Winchester Story) by Batman_out
29 parts Complete Mature
Two Hunters on their own, with nothing but their friendship to guide them, besides how they grew up, it had been a very successful two years. Until they run into two brothers. Read along as mysteries unfold themselves, love begins, the past coming back up again, and the journey of the Sisters and Winchesters start. ~ By: @Batman_out ~ Part 1 in the Sister's Series
The Hunters Nephilim by demilh
23 parts Complete Mature
The second book in the Hunters trilogy *************************************** You all remember Maeve Winchester. little sister of the Winchester brothers. oh and let's not forget Castiel her angel boyfriend. But what happens if she is pregnant will the Angels go are after her child ? or are it demons who want the baby? I guess you have to find out for yourselves. ***************************** I do not own the characters of Supernatural.!
Mourning Pie by DarkTwistedSisters
12 parts Complete Mature
BOOK 2 in our series 'Bakers, Hunters, and Pie... Oh My!' Life has been pretty good for our Bakers since they last met our favorite Hunters. But all that changes the morning they receive a strange call from John. Can the girls hold themselves together, bake a few pies and comfort the guys? Or will they each get lost in their own pain and suffering, leaving Bobby to pick up the pieces?
Fine Lines Between Heaven And Hell by BadAss_Cas
49 parts Complete
A young innocent teenage girl finally works up the nerve to ask her mother who her father is. After tedious research she finds herself meeting her father, Dean Winchester. Will she stick around after learning who the Winchesters really are?
(Book 1) Supernatural by Devin_B
23 parts Complete
Book 1 of Supernatural Series. Hi Wattpad Readers, If you have any questions, feel free to comment, plz star, and follow me for update announcements. It tells a story of two brothers Sam and Dean Winchester as they track down their father, John, who is on the trail of the yellow eyed demon who killed their mother and Sam's girlfriend. They attempt to discover the demon's plan for Sam and other psychic children, now young adults who were visited by Azazel as infants and given abilities, and whose mothers often died in a fire. During their travels, they use their father's journal to help them carry on the family business, saving people and hunting supernatural creatures. Join the Winchester's on their journey. Thanks for checking out the book! And any ideas are welcome, Hope you enjoy! Based off the TV show Supernatural STARTED: September 22, 2018 COMPLETED: October 12, 2018
The Hunters Sister ~Castiel by demilh
22 parts Complete Mature
The first book in the Hunters trilogy. ************************************* My name is Maeve Winchester. I'm the sister of the Winchester and we fight the Supernatural along with a certain Angel who is mabye more in the eyes of Maeve. ************************************ I don't own the characters of Supernatural.
A Supernatural Day at Stark Tower by WinchesterPeeps04
15 parts Complete
DISCONTINUED!!! We have a plan! This is an Avengers and Supernatural cross-over. We do not own anything to do with these universes. The only things we do own are Lillian and Jackson as they are our characters. ♡NOTE: LyricDaFerret is now LyricDaGoatLad♡ ☆Slow Updates☆ ♢Story by: GoddessLill and LyricDaGoatLad♢ ♤Cover by: GoddessLill♤ ♡Chapters Edited and Reviewed by LyricDaGoatLad♡ Here is the story of two different universes coming together. Lillian is a Hunter and Avenger in training. She is Sam Winchester's and Ruby's daughter and also, Jackson's niece. One day, she went on a vacation to New York and met the Avengers along the way. Jackson is the unknown brother to Sam and Dean Winchester. However, he and Lillian keep constant contact. Lillian informed Jackson about a case rising in New York and he and his brothers were quick to arrive. What is going to happen when the Hunters meet the Avengers? Read to find out.
Hope Isn't Far Away by wholockpotter67
15 parts Complete
PJ Collins was your average hunter. She ran into the Winchesters at Bobby's. After her visit she is bids them farewell. Two weeks later she runs into them again on a hunt. They decide to work together and find out they do pretty well together, so she sticks with them. After PJ assumes her past was buried, it decides to resurface. Can PJ keep it hidden from the brothers? What happens if they find out? Will things be the same? Only time will tell. Disclaimer: I do not own any of the Supernatural Characters(as much as I would like to I don't) I do however own PJ Collins and Chelsey Smith and others that are aren't apart of Supernatural(I'll let you guys know along the way)
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Cursed Pie? cover
Winchester Siblings: Capture (Book 1) (A Supernatural Series) cover
The Sisters (A Sam Winhester & Dean Winchester Story) cover
The Hunters Nephilim cover
Mourning Pie cover
Fine Lines Between Heaven And Hell cover
(Book 1) Supernatural cover
The Hunters Sister ~Castiel cover
A Supernatural Day at Stark Tower cover
Hope Isn't Far Away cover

Cursed Pie?

38 parts Complete Mature

Book 3: Dean and Sam return to Sioux Falls after they bring down Azazel, to keep a promise made in haste. They still have no idea what is going on with Lilly, the girl who incites rage and her sister who seems to know how they're feeling before they do. Can they help the bakers that have inexplicably become apart of their family? Or will they end up scaring them off with the darkness that comes with the life of hunting? It's been nearly a year since Lilly and Mae have seen the hunters but what will happen when they invite the brothers to stay? Besides Bobby throwing a fit of course... How will the girls handle the hunters and the life they lead when it's right in their face? Will they actually be able to accept it? Or will they run? Deceit and manipulation runs deep in this installment. Mae can tell the brothers are lying and even Lilly has her own suspicions, but they aren't the only ones keeping secrets... What will happen when the truth finally bubbles to the surface? Will the tension between Lilly and Dean finally break? Will the romance between Sam and Mae ever spark? Or will the lies douse the flame before it even gets a chance to light?

More details