I Love You But I Think I Need Him Too
CM5Hudson
  • Reads 18,958
  • Votes 511
  • Parts 100
  • Time 15h 25m
  • Reads 18,958
  • Votes 511
  • Parts 100
  • Time 15h 25m
CM5Hudson
Complete, First published Jul 15, 2017
Mature
finchelfinnfriendswithbenefitsgleegleeclubpuckpuckleberryrachelberryromancestberry
A story where a girl name Rachel Berry is stuck between her previous love with Finn Hudson and the new guy, Noah Puckerman. When Rachel shows the world her voice Finn realizes he need to treat her better before he loses her to Puck. Friendly Competition never hurt anybody right??? Oh so they thought. 
Based on some of my own true events. 

DISCLAIMER: its not how the show was but does have some parts to it.
All Rights Reserved
finchelfinnfriendswithbenefitsgleegleeclubpuckpuckleberryrachelberryromancestberry
Table of contents

100 parts

Sign up to add I Love You But I Think I Need Him Too to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
My Brother's Best Friend by MissMoncheleee
40 parts Complete
Big Brothers always make fun of little sisters, even if they're only two minutes apart. You see Rachel Berry-Puckerman is the 'younger' sister of McKinley's badass Noah Puckerman, like all siblings, they fight. The only time they get along is when they have to go to the foster home on olive street. Outside of school Puckermans stick together, due to the terrible home life. So being a good big brother puck looks out for his little sis. Even if it's from keeping slushies away or to having boys 100 feet away from her precious existence. Including his best friend Finn Hudson. What happens when pucks worst fear comes true, and his best bro falls for his little sis? Heartbreak and tension rises within the three causing trust issues and disagreement between the two close siblings.
My Best Friend by 0cecilia
21 parts Complete
Rachel Berry and Finn Hudson are best friends. Finn was always in love with Rachel and she never realized that she loved him too until after he got a girlfriend.
More Than A Hookup by timesoftrouble
109 parts Complete
Quinn and Puck are secretly hooking up with no strings attached, but what happens when one of them starts wanting more? DISCLAIMER: I DO NOT OWN GLEE OR ANY OF ITS CHARACTERS. ALL RIGHTS GO TO RYAN MURPHY, IAN BRENNAN, BRAD FALCHUK AND FOX. *originally published winter/spring 2019, edited January 2022*
Fifty Shades Of Finn: A Finchel FanFiction (Adult Content) by JarrettLeonard
30 parts Complete Mature
Rachel Berry, a graduate from Carmel High School for the past 3 years, has been living in New York with her best friend/Vocal Adrenaline partner Kurt Hummel. Rachel had recently been cast in a revival of Funny Girl and couldn't want anything more to go right, that is until she meets someone. Finn Hudson, who owns one of the biggest enterprises in New York, Hudson Enterprises. As Rachel soon meets Finn, things in her life start to go wrong, but some seem right. However, there's something that she finds out about Finn and it changes the way he feels towards, as a romance soon sparks between the two, but when old faces and new problems start to surface in Finn's life, he has to make decisions, and it's these decisions that could one day help him forget about his past, and leave his 50 shaded life behind him.
She Will Be Loved by Quinn5Hudson
31 parts Complete
Quinn and Finn are just friends best friends to be exact but there both secretly in love with each other. What happens when they fall in love with different people.
Captured (A Finchel Story) by josefinekn1999
31 parts Complete
On an excursion of their school to a prison, Rachel Berry, a 17 years old girl, meets the prisoner Finn Hudson. Shes totally amazed by him, but what did he do to get in there? And is Rachel really strong and brave enough to find out all of Finn's secrets?
need you now by MemoriesStories
33 parts Complete
♥COMPLETED♥ rachel schuester is a senior student on mckinley high school. she has a boyfriend named puck since junior year. rachel and puck are both in glee club were rachel her dad will is teaching. but what happend if her dad gets another job and there is a new teacher: finn hudson 28 years old. who is very handsome, nice and helps rachel with glee practice. will there be romance?? or will puck and rachel stay together??
Hate To Love by x_MFM_x
44 parts Complete
Hate To Love Ever hated that you love someone.. couldn't stop thinking about them? What and how would Finn and Rachel react to the situation targeted just for them. Along with senior year and friends turn against each other, fights, and heartbreaks. Keep reading to find out if they think these feelings are just a phase from spending so much time together or if being paired in English held there entire future. I DO NOT OWN GLEE ALL RIGHTS GO TO @RYANMURPHY & GLEE ORIGINAL WRITERS
Quickly In Love by 0cecilia
19 parts Complete
Finn needs a favor and Rachel is the only person that can help him. Falling in love was never a part of the plan but it just happened...But some people didn't enjoy that and will try their best to break the couple.
Being Rachel Berry by NatalieMccarthy1982
34 parts Complete
When moving to Lima , Ohio because of a tragedy Rachel Berry must come to terms with trying to heal herself. But when meeting Finn Hudson a boy who has struggles of his own Rachel starts to open up. Will she ever be able to trust anyone again or will one experience ruin everything. Find out in Being Rachel Berry a finchel story .
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
My Brother's Best Friend cover
My Best Friend cover
More Than A Hookup cover
Fifty Shades Of Finn: A Finchel FanFiction (Adult Content) cover
She Will Be Loved cover
Captured (A Finchel Story) cover
need you now cover
Hate To Love cover
Quickly In Love cover
Being Rachel Berry cover

My Brother's Best Friend

40 parts Complete

Big Brothers always make fun of little sisters, even if they're only two minutes apart. You see Rachel Berry-Puckerman is the 'younger' sister of McKinley's badass Noah Puckerman, like all siblings, they fight. The only time they get along is when they have to go to the foster home on olive street. Outside of school Puckermans stick together, due to the terrible home life. So being a good big brother puck looks out for his little sis. Even if it's from keeping slushies away or to having boys 100 feet away from her precious existence. Including his best friend Finn Hudson. What happens when pucks worst fear comes true, and his best bro falls for his little sis? Heartbreak and tension rises within the three causing trust issues and disagreement between the two close siblings.

More details