If Loving You Is Wrong - NothingButAShadow - Wattpad

Story cover for If Loving You Is Wrong by InTheirShadow

If Loving You Is Wrong

Reads 16,690
Votes 468
Parts 18
Time 1h 27m

Reads 16,690
Votes 468
Parts 18
Time 1h 27m

bendrowned bendrownedxticcitoby creepypasta eyelessjack sallywilliams slenderman ticcidrowned ticcitoby

(WARNING! THERE WILL BE DEPRESSING AND POSSIBLY TRIGGERING THINGS IN HERE) 
He grew up feeling like nobody would ever fall in love with him. Loving him was wrong. Thats what he believed. Everyone around him says that he's just a depressed little boy, not worth it, an emo psychopath, so he feels alone; but what happens when a new interest comes into the elven boy's life? But no one could love him, could they?
(Shitty description ik. Cover photo isn't mine. May have some smut/smex ;) )All Rights Reserved

bendrowned bendrownedxticcitoby creepypasta eyelessjack sallywilliams slenderman ticcidrowned ticcitoby

Table of contents

18 parts

Sign up to add If Loving You Is Wrong to your library and receive updates

or

#348sallywilliams

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) by SquishySmithIII

All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing *cough cough* Jeffrey Woods *cough cough* This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!

A New Life (Creepypasta x Reader) by __MissDreamer

Hello everyone! this is my very first story! So sorry if its not good...Anyways lets get started! If you don't have anything nice to say keep it to yourself please! This is my first story and I'm kind of nervous. Anyway please enjoy! (Y/n)= Your name

Ticci Toby wuvs Willow Wisp by JustAnAverageBunnie

Will Jameson is an average girl. Everything she knew changed in a matter of seconds. Her and her bestfriend, Jae get thrown off the road onto a willow tree. Just as Will thought her life couldn't get any worse, she lost something else. The one thing that kept her following her usual routine. Her sanity. After seeing the bloody body that once was Jae, she snapped. The feelings she had so carefully kept bottled up flooded through her veins. She killed any drunk man or woman she met in a less than forgettable fashion. This attracts the attention of the CreepyPasta. Now she has two options, join the other pastas, or kill them. (This is probably not the best description but it's the best I can do. This doesn't really tie into the title but as you read the story you will understand. And the title is a quote from the story.)

Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios! [complete] by BubbleTeaBts

Hello! Welcome to my book! By reading this you'll find out what its like to date these psychos. I'm sorry in advance for Out of character-ness and late updates (I'm trying okay?) Cover by: Keixel_0013 / Silent K I will be doing: Slenderman, Jeff the killer, BEN drowned , Masky, Hoodie, Sonic. exe, Ticci Toby,Eyeless Jack, lost silver and Dark Link comment if u want me to add any more (this Story is also on Quotev my user is Unicorngirl567 so if you see this story anywhere else besides here or my quotev please let me know! DISCLAIMER I DO NOT OWN ANY OF THE CREEPY PASTAS OR YOU I ONLY OWN MY KEYBOARD

Love Is Blind (Eyeless Jack x Reader) by DarkRaven2994

(Y/n) was just your average, everyday young adult who loved to read books, take walks, and enjoy the beautiful scenery that the woods just beyond her backyard had to offer. Life without the daily struggle of completing schoolwork was long gone and liberating. However, true freedom was not so easily obtained when you lived under the rule of abusive parents. (Y/n) is determined to make it through another year of mistreatment, but once newfound tragedies occur, hope in withstanding the circumstances starts to falter . . . That is, until a newfound stranger enters her life. There's something off about him at first, but as time passes, she slowly regains her optimism as well as some other new-felt feelings. A new life seems to be forming before her eyes, but is this new life something that she can handle?

Strange Love (Eyeless jack X reader) by DemonAngel1881

SOOOO you just gotta read to find out lololollllll Ye Imma annoy ya with that But come on, you fall in love with a killer that has to be some strange love yo (All credits to artist of cover)

Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby by 1800-WERE-FCKING-GAY

He killed his dad, found a new home, finally settled in, even made some new friends. What else? Oh yeah, and watched his crush get brutally murdered and sacrificed by a cult.

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) by clear-quartz

||WARNING! THIS BOOK HAS BEEN ABANDONED!|| (Y/N) had always been a seemingly normal guy. Never really causing trouble, had great friends and a loving sister, but he had struggles that little to no one knew about. One day, though, that all changed with a few simple actions done by another. A/N I do not own any of the Creepypastas, art, or videos (unless said otherwise) in this story (sadly). All credit goes to the original creators.

Color My Life (Candy Pop x Slenderman's daughter reader) by SarahMKJ

White skin. Black eyes. White lips. Black tentacle hair. White pointed teeth. Black dress. Y/n has a protective father and is given limited time outside. She has no favorite color and no favorite hobby other than reading and killing. She is outside only during moon-lit nights. White moon. Black sky. White stars. Black shadows. There is no such thing as color to her. Only black, white, and gray. Light and shadow is the only thing she knows. My first two creepypasta x reader books had a picture on each chapter. They are pretty time-consuming and difficult to make. If you all want me to still do them I will. Just let me know :).

A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING] by VCReading1098

Cover By: mrsagustd93 Y/N L/N-Age 19 She had a friend from her past disappear. People say he's dead. Others say he's alive and killing. She wish both of these remarks aren't true and he's just at a vacation for a long time... Tobias Rodgers Aka. Ticci Toby- Age 19 One of the proxies of Slenderman. Doesn't really remember some of his past from a little bit of amnesia. Can't feel pain from one of his disorders. Has Tourette's Syndrome. What happens if they meet again? ⚠️CONTAINS GORE, BAD LANGUAGE⚠️

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) cover

A New Life (Creepypasta x Reader) cover

Ticci Toby wuvs Willow Wisp cover

Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios! [complete] cover

Love Is Blind (Eyeless Jack x Reader) cover

Strange Love (Eyeless jack X reader) cover

Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby cover

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) cover

Color My Life (Candy Pop x Slenderman's daughter reader) cover

A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING] cover

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader)

All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing cough cough Jeffrey Woods cough cough This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!