The other path (HTTYD Hiccup x OC)

As soon as Hiccup was declared the winner and to fight the Monstrous Nightmare he leaves in the middle of the night on Toothless. Landing on an island far away that has a village too, there he notices that not all vikings are against keeping dragons, especially not when he is invited to watch the race with the chief of the village. Of course he knows he has to return one day, but he found a place where he could be himself, a strange roar scares all the dragons at night and he wants to find out. The question is, how is he going to do that without any help?

(In this story Toothless has a complete tail and Hiccup never loses his foot)