Mr. Nice Guy - TheReturnOfTurtle - Wattpad

Mr. Nice Guy

TheReturnOfTurtle

Reads 24,528
Votes 1,028
Parts 5
Time 44m

Reads 24,528
Votes 1,028
Parts 5
Time 44m

TheReturnOfTurtle

anger depression fakesmiles fanfiction frisk genocide grillby insainty love pacifist papyrus resets romance sans smiles spacetime suicidal timelines toriel undertale

Finally, after all these resets, it appears they finally got their "happy" ending. 
  
 However, not all of them feel the same way.
  
 Flowey and Sans are the two left who remember what happened, and they are filled with resentment. Just the knowledge of the resets can be nearly maddening. However, Sans keeps his smile. But one day, he realizes...

He doesn't want to be Mr. Nice Guy anymore.All Rights Reserved

anger depression fakesmiles fanfiction frisk genocide grillby insainty love pacifist papyrus resets romance sans smiles spacetime suicidal timelines toriel undertale

Table of contents

5 parts

Sign up to add Mr. Nice Guy to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Undertale - Fighting To Stay [Frans] [Book 3] by SepticGirl88

So, monsters and humans have been living together on the surface for quite a few years now... That's an accomplishment! No resets, no new timeline. Just a future continuing forward like everyone could have possibly hoped for. However, not everything is hopeful. You can't expect to live a life where everything is sunshine and rainbows. Even with no longer having the threat of someone like Chara, things can still happen when you least expect them to. You can't always have your "Happy Ending".

Sans' House Guests (CreepyPasta x Undertale) by BubblyShip

The surface was not what Sans thought it would be. Lack of communication skills, communication in general, and social interaction had driven him into a depressed and anxious state of loneliness so deep that it'd take a gang of serial killers to help drag him out and fix his problems. Literally, it took a gang of murderers called CreepyPasta just to set things right. The world acts in funny ways. (REWRITE IN PROGRESS - Be warned, this story is old and is not properly written to handle certain topics regarding mental health.)

Some Time To Kill (UndertalexCreepypasta) by shxbwesx

Sans' life on the surface has been going well enough, but how long will it last. Will Frisk take it all away with another reset? Too much paranoia can attract attention... (This is an Undertale and creepypasta crossover I hope you enjoy :P) (Inspired by BubblyShip (marry me))

No More (Undertale) by ANinnyMouse42

For years, Papyrus knows, Sans has had nightmares. Horrible nightmares, nightmares that leave him crying in the dark, crippled in the mind, and barely able to function in life. And that's why Papyrus stays so happy, so bright, for Sans, to keep his brother going through the hard times. But when Papyrus starts having nightmares, he knows something is wrong. And even if it means Sans is finally stepping up to fend for himself, even if he's finally once again filling the role of the protective older brother, Papyrus knows that something dark is coming...

Undertale: Resurrected by authorofworlds

After many resets, Frisk finally decides to finish with a Pacifist Run and let everyone have their happy ending. With humans and monsters slowly coming together, everything seems to be falling into place and he couldn't be happier. But Frisk remembers something: The other six human souls. Their bodies were left in the Underground without a proper burial, one of which they deserve. However, when he and Toriel go up to retrieve the bodies of the children, they discover something rather unexpected.

Afterflower by CutiePieViv

Sans fell into deep despair after Frisk's death. He wished to see them again, to smile, to laugh with them just like before. But what would he do, if he had the power to reset? The chance to create a new world where they could both be happy? Would he take that chance? Even if it meant risking his soul? //Just letting you all know that this takes place after the Undertale AU called Flowerfell. I did not make flowerfell, but I am the creator of this au AfterFlower.

An Underswap AU: A Tale of Seven Book 1 by sabermoonlight1616

The Multiverse is vast, expanding continuously as more alternate dimensions are being created. Each world possesses it's own unique laws, stories and inhabitants. This world in particular, based on the well known Underswap Canon Universe, happens to revolve around three important questions. What if the first six humans who fell after Frisk never left the Ruins? What if the world is slowly succumbing to the corruption caused by the RESETs? And. . . What if Sans' cooking improved? A/N This is my own interpretation of Grouptale, in the Underswap Universe. Please read the Disclaimer and Warnings.

Fonttale by MegynHamilton

Fonttale is an AU where skeletons have a special power related to their font name. A Normal Font Comic Sans for example, can force people to laugh. However, Papyrus is a Horror Font and they're much different from Normal Fonts. This is where and why the story begins. Papyrus is a sadistic murder whose main goal is to protect his one HP brother Sans. By day he pretends to be an obnoxious idiotic skeleton obsessed with puzzles and spaghetti, but at night he teams up with Flowey and patrols the area for humans in order to collect souls to break the barrier. When he isn't doing that he visits the MTT Resort where his brother does his comedic acts and kills monsters he finds in the alley in order to keep Sans safe. Unfortunately as time passes and more and more monsters disappear, the "Resort Killer" becomes everyone's favorite topic...including Undyne's. When Papyrus decides one day to take a chance, something goes wrong and Sans discovers more than he ever wanted to about Papyrus, the Underground, and even himself. The line between right and wrong becomes a blur, and his relationship with his brother is tested as he tries to help him overcome his apparent madness. But is it really Papyrus that needs help?

Crossing the Limit (Undertale) by Espeon804

(Alternate Ending added!) "If you solve your problems with kindness instead of violence, then everyone wins! Violence isn't necessary! It only hurts people! It can sometimes make the conflict worse!" ----------------------------------------------------------------- He's kind. He's gentle. He is so forgiving. He always welcomed a stranger with open arms. He wouldn't hurt a fly. It's disgusting. But that is why Papyrus never fails to catch Flowey's interest. So, Flowey decides to cross a line. A line that is the border between forgiveness and retaliation. Rated T for violence and some language.

My Love and Yours by Flare787

Sequel to Emotions A few weeks have passed since Chara had regained her lost Soul and survived. Now, she is currently dating Frisk and Flowey has been able to feel emotions once more as he had been when he was once Asriel. Now, the girls, assisted by the Fallen Humans, are now starting to try and make another couple happen under this roof. With a jealous ex just close by, and more trouble brews with a new arrival, can they accomplish their new goal?

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Undertale - Fighting To Stay [Frans] [Book 3] cover

Sans' House Guests (CreepyPasta x Undertale) cover

Some Time To Kill (UndertalexCreepypasta) cover

No More (Undertale) cover

Undertale: Resurrected cover

Afterflower cover

An Underswap AU: A Tale of Seven Book 1 cover

Crossing the Limit (Undertale) cover

My Love and Yours cover

Undertale - Fighting To Stay [Frans] [Book 3]

So, monsters and humans have been living together on the surface for quite a few years now... That's an accomplishment! No resets, no new timeline. Just a future continuing forward like everyone could have possibly hoped for. However, not everything is hopeful. You can't expect to live a life where everything is sunshine and rainbows. Even with no longer having the threat of someone like Chara, things can still happen when you least expect them to. You can't always have your "Happy Ending".