Mr. Nice Guy - TheReturnOfTurtle - Wattpad

Mr. Nice Guy

TheReturnOfTurtle

Reads 24,540
Votes 1,033
Parts 5
Time 44m

Reads 24,540
Votes 1,033
Parts 5
Time 44m

TheReturnOfTurtle

anger depression fakesmiles fanfiction frisk genocide grillby insainty love pacifist papyrus resets romance sans smiles spacetime suicidal timelines toriel undertale

Finally, after all these resets, it appears they finally got their "happy" ending. 
  
 However, not all of them feel the same way.
  
 Flowey and Sans are the two left who remember what happened, and they are filled with resentment. Just the knowledge of the resets can be nearly maddening. However, Sans keeps his smile. But one day, he realizes...

He doesn't want to be Mr. Nice Guy anymore.All Rights Reserved

anger depression fakesmiles fanfiction frisk genocide grillby insainty love pacifist papyrus resets romance sans smiles spacetime suicidal timelines toriel undertale

Table of contents

5 parts

Sign up to add Mr. Nice Guy to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Undertale - Fighting To Stay [Frans] [Book 3] by SepticGirl88

So, monsters and humans have been living together on the surface for quite a few years now... That's an accomplishment! No resets, no new timeline. Just a future continuing forward like everyone could have possibly hoped for. However, not everything is hopeful. You can't expect to live a life where everything is sunshine and rainbows. Even with no longer having the threat of someone like Chara, things can still happen when you least expect them to. You can't always have your "Happy Ending".

Underswap!Papyrus x Reader by rorkitten

You have lived in the underground for 4 months now, and had befriended the most adorable cinnamon roll ever, Sans. However, you couldn't help but to gain feelings for his brother, Papyrus, even if Papyrus pretty much hated you. Could you change his mind? Get him to fall in love with you? There was only one way to find out. Reader's gender is not specified! Also Papyrus doesn't smoke in this story, sorry if you wanted that! Credit to Dizplicity for the artwork! Please check them out, they're amazing! http://dizplicity.deviantart.com/

Undertale: Resurrected by authorofworlds

After many resets, Frisk finally decides to finish with a Pacifist Run and let everyone have their happy ending. With humans and monsters slowly coming together, everything seems to be falling into place and he couldn't be happier. But Frisk remembers something: The other six human souls. Their bodies were left in the Underground without a proper burial, one of which they deserve. However, when he and Toriel go up to retrieve the bodies of the children, they discover something rather unexpected.

Don't Forget [Sans x Female Reader] by GabrielXander

You would think that with how shit your luck is, you would've been dead day one since falling into the Underground filled with scary monsters and a few spooky skeletons. However, much to your surprise, that did not happen (yet). You know how you ended up here, but you don't know... HOW. You're actually in the GAME Undertale now. And to make matters worse, there are some people who KNOW. You're surviving the best you can, but things are only going to get weirder from here on out. Gaster apparently needs your help? You're using the DJ to go to different AU's? You are gay now?- Okay, maybe that last one is just a joke, but still! You can only hope that your instincts are enough to keep you alive in these trenches. On God, they tryin' to drown you in this hoe! {Available on Patreon, Quotev, and Ao3 under GabrielXander}

Into The Game >> (Sans X Reader) Undertale FanFiction by Melody4164

It was just a normal Saturday. (Y/N) was playing Undertale for the millionth time. She was obsessed. (Y/N) had played all of the routes. True Pacifist, No Mercy/Genocide, Neutral. She experimented with killing certain characters doing different things. Then, as (Y/N) started a new game, she felt a falling sensation, as if she just fell out of her chair. She blacked out soon after. When she woke up, she was lying on a bed of golden flowers. She knew this place. (Y/N) was in the game. She had taken the place of Frisk and was in the Underground. •Disclaimer I do not own Undertale. It belongs to Toby Fox. I do not own you. You own yourself. I do not own the cover or any of the pictures that will show up in this book• *If you're reading this as a guy please just change the pronouns to he/him/his. I find if a lot easier to just put female pronouns. Thanks! :3 *

The Woman of My Dreams (Sans x Toriel) by TheStickStudios

After Frisk broke the barrier and freed all monsters, life has been hard for humans to cope with their new friends. But even if life is hard trying to suit their new lifestyle, everyone will stick together as long as they have the boss monsters sticking around. Ever since Frisk became the ambassador of monsters he has been excruciatingly trying to get the word out that monsters do no harm. But after a few weeks on the surface, two monsters have feelings for each other. They both can't express their feelings, but it's only a matter of time until they fall in love with each other and start a new life together. A life they won't forget.

Chainsmoker [ Gaster!Sans x Reader ] by morrow-

Routine. The entirety of every living thing is dominated by it, human or monster. Everything HAS to be the same. It was in this that you were the exception. For you everything was new, every time line a detailed altered in order to satisfy your sadistic desire for a new ending, whether it be only a few details of dialogue altered or something else entirely. Monsters you once considered family you now butcher and slaughter without a second thought, after all, that's what the Reset is there for, right? And all at once it stops. Your small hold over the Underground is ripped away from you and you are thrown into a dying timeline, monsterkind's final attempt at self-preservation. You're alone, completely and utterly alone. Except one. And he has a bone to pick with you.

My Love and Yours by Flare787

Sequel to Emotions A few weeks have passed since Chara had regained her lost Soul and survived. Now, she is currently dating Frisk and Flowey has been able to feel emotions once more as he had been when he was once Asriel. Now, the girls, assisted by the Fallen Humans, are now starting to try and make another couple happen under this roof. With a jealous ex just close by, and more trouble brews with a new arrival, can they accomplish their new goal?

Crossing the Limit (Undertale) by Espeon804

(Alternate Ending added!) "If you solve your problems with kindness instead of violence, then everyone wins! Violence isn't necessary! It only hurts people! It can sometimes make the conflict worse!" ----------------------------------------------------------------- He's kind. He's gentle. He is so forgiving. He always welcomed a stranger with open arms. He wouldn't hurt a fly. It's disgusting. But that is why Papyrus never fails to catch Flowey's interest. So, Flowey decides to cross a line. A line that is the border between forgiveness and retaliation. Rated T for violence and some language.

Some Time To Kill (UndertalexCreepypasta) by shxbwesx

Sans' life on the surface has been going well enough, but how long will it last. Will Frisk take it all away with another reset? Too much paranoia can attract attention... (This is an Undertale and creepypasta crossover I hope you enjoy :P) (Inspired by BubblyShip (marry me))

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Undertale - Fighting To Stay [Frans] [Book 3] cover

Underswap!Papyrus x Reader cover

Undertale: Resurrected cover

Don't Forget [Sans x Female Reader] cover

Into The Game >> (Sans X Reader) Undertale FanFiction cover

The Woman of My Dreams (Sans x Toriel) cover

Chainsmoker [ Gaster!Sans x Reader ] cover

My Love and Yours cover

Crossing the Limit (Undertale) cover

Some Time To Kill (UndertalexCreepypasta) cover

Undertale - Fighting To Stay [Frans] [Book 3]

So, monsters and humans have been living together on the surface for quite a few years now... That's an accomplishment! No resets, no new timeline. Just a future continuing forward like everyone could have possibly hoped for. However, not everything is hopeful. You can't expect to live a life where everything is sunshine and rainbows. Even with no longer having the threat of someone like Chara, things can still happen when you least expect them to. You can't always have your "Happy Ending".