I Don't Believe We've Met

Dan has a nasty break up with Phil after he finds out Phil had slept with some girl at age 15 and getting her pregnant, leaving him stuck with baby Janis at age 16. Dan becomes depressed and in a last attempt to not finally end it all, he hears about a new kind of treatment where they can remove certain memories from a person's mind. Years afterwards Dan starts a babysitting business where he has the pleasure of meeting Janis Lester and her dad, Phil Lester, who swears him and Dan were together but Dan keeps swearing they never met before.