I Trusted You (Peter Pan)
queenofthelamas
  • Reads 4,237
  • Votes 90
  • Parts 14
  • Time 5h 42m
  • Reads 4,237
  • Votes 90
  • Parts 14
  • Time 5h 42m
queenofthelamas
Complete, First published Sep 01, 2017
lostboyneverlandonceuponatimeouatpanpeterpeterpanprophecyrevengeromance
'Nothing could ruin Cassandra's good mood, not even Emma Swan or her Storybrooke friends. Not when Cassandra was with Peter. 

For he was hers and she was his.'
_____

All heroes need a tragic backstory. 
All stories need a knight in shining armour.

Cassandra had her troubled past. She had her knight in shining armour, if one could call him that. Unfortunately, in this tale, our protagonist is no heroine, and her saviour is no hero.
She has a thirst for revenge, and it just so happens to coincide with Peter Pan's plot for eternal youth. All she needs to do, to fulfil both their wishes, is help Pan kill the Truest Believer.
The fact that the Truest Believer was also the twin she had never met, placed no burden on her shoulders.
All Rights Reserved
lostboyneverlandonceuponatimeouatpanpeterpeterpanprophecyrevengeromance
Table of contents

14 parts

Sign up to add I Trusted You (Peter Pan) to your library and receive updates
or
#478prophecy
Content Guidelines
You may also like
He was Peter Before Pan (Once Upon a Time/Peter Pan) by full_of_dreams_
40 parts Complete
What if there was a time when Peter Pan wasn't evil, when he was the way every fairy tale book portrayed him? I wouldn't be lying when I said there was. In Maine there is a small town known as Storybooke. You may think you know everything about it, and everyone in it. But I can guarantee you there is one you have not met. 18 year old Haven, was once a girl who never grew up, in a land that is every child's imagination. She's always been an orphan, that was until Snow and Emma took her in. She always refused to tell anyone about her past. And that was only because it involves the one and only Peter Pan. What happens when she joins Emma to find Henry at Neverland?
Run Little Lost Girl by xXQueen_of_ThievesXx
27 parts Complete
After Wendy Darling left Neverland and later died, Peter Pan was never the same. Heartbroken, he became dark and ruthless and replaced all his jolly lost boys for ones that killed as a sport. Peter believed that he would never be good hearted again. At least, not on his own. So he came up with a plan to take a descendant of Wendy's to Neverland so that he could possibly learn to be good again and save Neverland from rotting in eternal darkness. But there's one problem: He took the wrong girl. ⋆✶ ☆ #22 in adventure, #1 in tinkerbell, #3 in lostboys, #1 in lostgirl, #7 in Hook, #1 in darling, #10 in Neverland, and many more ☆ [Ranks last updated on: 17 April 2019] 【The character, Peter Pan, in this story was inspired by OUAT's Peter Pan, however, the storyline is 100% mine and does not correlate to the show. All rights reserved】 【COMPLETE and FULLY EDITED】
✓ | ANGEL BY THE WINGS ➸ PETER PAN by wickedivory
62 parts Complete Mature
━ 𝐀𝐍𝐆𝐄𝐋 𝐁𝐘 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐖𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒. ❛ she is falling, falling, falling ❜ in which peter pan falls in love with a girl who hates herself. • completed • trigger warning! • ooc!peter pan • cover credit: me • story layout: me
The Untold Past of Pan by weasleypan5
14 parts Complete
A very long time ago, you fell in love with a boy named Malcolm, and he blessed you with a son. Only problem? You're Hecate, goddess of magic, and you were forced to abandon them to complete your godly duties. But now, years later, Pan has captured your great-grandson Henry and is holding him captive on Neverland, a place you created. But will your resurfacing love for Pan prevent you from doing what needs to be done? Killing him? *I do not own any of the characters in this story* **Not entirely accurate to the plot of OUAT** ***Thank you Robbie Kay for being hot*** ****Small smut warning****
The Monster Inside Peter Pan (ouat)//(Robbie Kay) by x0xShadowangel
89 parts Complete Mature
Peter Pan never thought he'd do anything selfless. He never thought he'd want to die. He never thought he'd be able to love. He never thought he'd see all consuming love in someone's eyes as they looked at him. Yet Peter Pan hadn't met Alianna. That girl. That girl that gave everything up in a heartbeat to save her brother. The girl he tortured and tormented for his pleasure. The girl who refused to see the world in black and white, but preferred varying shades of grey. Pan knew that he was black, pitch black, and that there was no redemption for him, yet she insisted that he was only a dark, dark shade of grey. Had she not seen that speck of white, things would've been so much simpler for both of them. For when the moment Pan had been waiting all his life finally came, he did the the only thing he'd never thought he'd do. He refused. Little sneak peek of Pan's letters: Oh god, I loved her. I loved her so much, and it pained me for her to remain ignorant of my feelings. Because that night, I realized that seeing her and hearing her wasn't enough. I wanted to smell her scent, feel her soft skin against mine, taste her lips. But I wanted more than that. I wanted her to love me too. I wanted her to love me for everything that I was. The good and the bad, the light and the dark. I wanted her to love me like only she could, accepting the entirety of my deeply flawed self, fixing them with a simple touch, melting away my fears with a single smile, change me into the man I wanted to be for her with a single kiss. (Completed) Highest ranking: #1 Neverland #1 Peter Pan #1 lost girl #1 onceuponatime #2 monster
Innocence (OUAT/Peter Pan) by kay_writes_dragons
51 parts Complete
A girl doomed before her own birth to be violently wanted by every person in her entire world, and then imprisoned for her entire life starting at age 5, of course wants nothing more than to escape. His Shadow is called to her, and takes her to Neverland, where she gets her freedom. And when you give an evil boy an innocent girl, opposites attract. I love the TV series, but I think Peter Pan should get to love somebody, so here's who and here's how they fell in love, as I believe it should go. Sorry for the bad summary, I promise the story is better! *Rating cautious, may change for some chapters TBA **I do not own the Once Upon a Time TV series, nor do I own their characters. I do own this story, and my main female character. ***Copyright***
The Lost Girl (ouat Peter Pan x Reader) by Myfroststory
32 parts Complete
After spending most of your life in foster and your brother leaving you, you start to lose all hope. Until one night a shadow appears at your window and takes you to Neverland where you meet Peter Pan. While at Neverland you discover your own secrets and find something new that you had never experienced. See how Peter was turned into the monster he is today. Discover who really made others "protect" magic. The real question is: do villains get happy endings?
Neverland (Peter Pan OUAT x Reader) by beano1368
20 parts Complete
Taken from your true home you end up in the Enchanted Forest, living with the Evil Queen. During the dark curse you found Henry, your step brother. Together you helped Emma break the curse, but nothing in Storybrooke is ever simple. When two newcomers kidnap your mother it's just the start of a new mystery. What will happen when you get taken to Neverland along with Henry? What hidden truths will be revealed? Armed with your fighting skills and wit on an island where nothing is as it seems, you are determined to protect Henry from Peter Pan. But is Pan the true villain? The game is only just beginning, and we all know...Peter Pan never fails. -This is based around season 3. Regina is friends with the Charming's. For the sake of the storyline Peter is not Rumples father.- *I do not own any characters of ouat- just y/n and the plot of this story* IF THIS IS PUBLISHED ANYWHERE OTHER THAN WATTPAD IT HAS BEEN STOLEN First published 2022 Ranks: 1 in ouatneverland (14/1/23) 1 in lostboys (28/12/22) 3 in pirate (3/12/22) 5 in feamalereader (10/2/23) 6 in mysteryromance (6/11/22) 13 in peterpan (14/11/22) 9 in femalereader (23/2/23) 52 in fanfiction (23/2/23) 1 in peterpan (14/7/23)
A Pirate's Revenge (Peter Pan OUAT x Y/N Jones) - Slow updates by Devyn54
115 parts Ongoing Mature
After Pan takes Henry from Storybrooke, Y/N Jones joins her dad and fellow heroes on a quest to get him back. But what happens when along the way, Y/N meets Peter and realizes that she's not being treated right? Is there another way to save Peter? Find out in A Pirate's Revenge. *I do not own the OUAT plot line or Peter Pan only Y/N. I follow the beginning of the series word for word with a few changes in it so those of you that haven't seen it can understand.* *slow-burn *smut involved *strong language used
•Mind Games • peter pan and Wendy darling by Iamrachelyouaregorgx
19 parts Complete
1ST BOOK IN THE PAN/WENDY ROMANCE SERIES. He's the hero in my nightmares and the villain in my dreams <3 "peter pan. Never fails". Wendy is slowly learning that Pan is not peter. And the boy she loved might have fallen down a rabbit hole he cannot escape, that if he wanted to anyway.
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
He was Peter Before Pan (Once Upon a Time/Peter Pan) cover
Run Little Lost Girl cover
✓ | ANGEL BY THE WINGS ➸ PETER PAN cover
The Untold Past of Pan cover
The Monster Inside Peter Pan (ouat)//(Robbie Kay) cover
Innocence (OUAT/Peter Pan) cover
The Lost Girl (ouat Peter Pan x Reader) cover
Neverland (Peter Pan OUAT x Reader) cover
A Pirate's Revenge (Peter Pan OUAT x Y/N Jones) - Slow updates cover
•Mind Games • peter pan and Wendy darling cover

He was Peter Before Pan (Once Upon a Time/Peter Pan)

40 parts Complete

What if there was a time when Peter Pan wasn't evil, when he was the way every fairy tale book portrayed him? I wouldn't be lying when I said there was. In Maine there is a small town known as Storybooke. You may think you know everything about it, and everyone in it. But I can guarantee you there is one you have not met. 18 year old Haven, was once a girl who never grew up, in a land that is every child's imagination. She's always been an orphan, that was until Snow and Emma took her in. She always refused to tell anyone about her past. And that was only because it involves the one and only Peter Pan. What happens when she joins Emma to find Henry at Neverland?

More details