Mafia Man's Kitten

Suddenly I hear a chuckle above me. No, multiple chuckles above me. My eyes pop open and all I can do is stare at the wall of guys. I glance over all five of them. Then my eyes zoom in on the man that has his arms around my waist. " I-I'm s-sor-ry" I Stutter out. " I didn't m-mean to b-bump into yo-ou. I wasn't w-watching where I w-was going." "Sshh shh shh kitten it's alright," he says with a little smirk. "I-I-I." "Now now kitten I said it's alright," he says with a slight accent while wiping away a stray tear I didn't even know had fallen. "So don't you worry your pretty little head about it." Then I hear a chorus of 'aawws'. I think I even hear one of the guys ask the one in front of me, who is still holding me, mind you. "Can we keep her?"
I had no idea that one big, intimidating man would walk in one day and change everything for me. The question is, will it be a good or bad change?