When It's Right, It's Right - JenJen - Wattpad

When It's Right, It's Right

Reads 18,511
Votes 706
Parts 17
Time 2h 14m

Reads 18,511
Votes 706
Parts 17
Time 2h 14m

Mature

alternateuniverse finn finnfiction firsttime gilmoregirls loganhuntzberger pdld romance rorygilmore roryxfinn

Starts off at "Wedding Bell Blues" Slightly AU- Rory and Logan start out the way they did on the show. However, Rory is still a virgin and Logan is not a big fan of being someone's first- he can't handle the emotional baggage that tends to come with it. Rory knows Logan won't stick around if she's still the big V which leads us to her trusty friend Finn. He's been helping her out with a class they take together and they spend a lot of time together, as well all the things they've discovered they have in common.

How will things with Rory and Logan pan out and will Rory see the caring and kind guy who's been there all along?

I have tested the first few chapters out on another website but I am getting some much-needed editing and content help from Mindy Root so things might be a little slow going at first. Hope you all like the idea I know we have a bunch of Finn fans on here so enjoy!

Also, credit goes to AshleyWheeler1 for helping me out when I needed the motivation to keep going
RATED M!All Rights Reserved

alternateuniverse finn finnfiction firsttime gilmoregirls loganhuntzberger pdld romance rorygilmore roryxfinn

Table of contents

17 parts

Sign up to add When It's Right, It's Right to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Patchwork heart by annelisefinn

Logan centric fanfic that takes place a three years after season 7. He's back in NYC trying to launch a new business with his friends Colin and Finn. He's out from his father's grasp, trying to make it on his own, but his heart still has some mending to do from the way he left things with Rory. Unexpectedly the two will meet again, but with too much baggage between them, the two start off as friends - until one day that is no longer believable. Later might be switched to Mature rating.

Tangled Hearts by RennyTee

[BOOK 1] "I won't leave" I whisper, and he smiles, "I know, baby" he says softly, and my lips tug upwards into a smile. "You're the exception" he continued, his tone tender as he pressed a short, sweet kiss to my forehead. I didn't know it then, but I started falling in love with Finn Brookes, we were each other's exceptions. * * * Lily Garcia didn't come to university looking for love-especially not with someone like Finn Brooks. He's charming, infuriating, and a walking complication she doesn't need. But no matter how hard she tries to keep her distance, there's something about him that feels like gravity, pulling her closer with every encounter. Beneath his cocky exterior, she senses the fractures he tries to hide-the same ones she's been running from her entire life. Finn's been through hell, and love isn't part of the plan. He's good at keeping his walls high, locking out anyone who might get too close. But then Lily shows up, and suddenly his carefully controlled life begins to unravel. She's everything he didn't know he was missing, and that scares him more than he's willing to admit. But with their pasts threatening to destroy what they could be, and old friends trying to drive a wedge between them, trust becomes their biggest hurdle. And when a new love interest steps into the picture, everything Lily and Finn thought they were building starts to fall apart. Fighting their demons was never supposed to include each other, but now they have to decide if the risk of heartbreak is worth the reward of finally letting someone in.

The Scarecrow by MindyRoot

At the end of Gilmore Girls: A Year In the Life, Rory finds herself carrying a permanent reminder of Logan. She unexpectedly finds comfort in the arms of a friend. Follow on the journey of Rory and Finn as their love blooms from a delicate friendship. These are ASP's characters, I'm just using them to create my own twist! :-) It's my own Finn-fiction!

It All Started At Yale (After AYITL) by Kenna_kitty_roawr

Rory's pregnant. Will she tell Logan? Heartache strikes, relationships bent, and more. This is book 1 and there will be a book 2. (Completed) I'm not very good at descriptions 😂. Sorry. I do not own any of the Gilmore Girls Characters. This is just my version of what would happen after those final four words... Enjoy!

Gilmore Girls: Precious Ties by HelenLouise7

Following Gilmore Girls A Year In The Life, this fanfic focuses on the many precious relationships that flourish as a result of Rory's pregnancy. Her love life has been unconventional up to this point and things are about to rise to a new level of "complicated" as this story progresses! Will she find love? The best answer is probably that love will find her! It will change her in ways she wouldn't have ever expected!

Extraordinary Love - Rory and Logan by jaclynqqn

A fanfiction of the Gilmore Girls, sets five years after Rory graduated Yale and rejected Logan's proposal. Life had took them pretty far before meeting them again. So many obstacles are in their way, but their love is extraordinary, isn't it? Will Rory and Logan got through the obstacles and find their ways into each other again? Disclaimer: I don't own any credits from the characters, and this story is not connected with "A Year in the Life". Although I took some of the characters names from it. Also, the pictures were all from the internet, so if you are the rightful owner of any of the pictures, please message me... thank you 😉

The Hayden Dream Girl | logan huntzberger [ON HIATUS] by margaretx334

Matilda Hayden grew up with her father in the Elite Upper Class of Boston, and she quite enjoyed her life- thank you very much. She didn't have many complaints. She was going to be attending Yale, her dream school. She had her best friends with her, and she was on the dance team. But there's one wrench in her newfound college life- a long lost twin sister and the mom who didn't want her. ~ [gilmore girls seasons 4-7] [eventual logan x fem!oc] kind of a slowburn I don't own Gilmore Girls or their characters, only my characters and their storylines.

Come Back...Be Here (Gilmore Girls Post-AYITL) by G-Girl2017

If you've not seen A Year in the Life yet then this will contain spoilers! Following on from the final 4 words - story is centred around Rory/Logan and what happens next... This is my first attempt at fan fiction so please be gentle - I hope to update regularly, at least 2-3 times a week. Title comes from the track by Taylor Swift that totally inspired me - can't help but think of Rory and Logan when I hear this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OQW88-yPys *This story is my original work but is fan fiction and the characters and places in this story do not belong to me*

Then you came along (A Robert/Tristan fanfic) by CrystalAllen675

Rory is a Sophomore at Yale, she is crazy about Logan, but he wants to be a playboy. She gets invited to Finn's birthday party by Robert. Logan is very jealous; he wants Rory to leave with him, and Rory says no. What will happen between Rory and Robert? Will he commit to her? Does she love Logan? Does she love Robert? What will Lorelai say? Later, when tragedy strikes, how will Rory cope? Will she go back to her playboy? Will she find love from the sexy Australian playboy? Or will her high school nemesis strike her interest? So, many questions; read the story to get the answers. *There will be parts of the series that happened and other parts that didn't* **I do not own any part or Gilmore girl characters; those rights are reserved by the original writer Amy Sherman Palladino** I only own the rights to my original characters

Once in a lifetime (A FinnFic) by CrystalAllen675

Rory is a sophomore at Yale when she meets three snobs who think they are better than everyone else just because they have money. She isn't interested in any of them but then she starts to write a story on a secret society and falls for Logan but he won't commit to her and she decides to end their relationship. Then another one of the guys steps out of the shadows can he commit or will Rory get her heart broken again if she falls for Finn? This story is written as if seasons 5-7 and AYITL didn't happen the way they did on the show. I do not own the rights to the characters in this story only the ones I came up with. All rights are owned by Amy Palladino and the writers of Gilmore Girls.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Patchwork heart cover

Tangled Hearts cover

The Scarecrow cover

It All Started At Yale (After AYITL) cover

Gilmore Girls: Precious Ties cover

Extraordinary Love - Rory and Logan cover

The Hayden Dream Girl | logan huntzberger [ON HIATUS] cover

Come Back...Be Here (Gilmore Girls Post-AYITL) cover

Then you came along (A Robert/Tristan fanfic) cover

Once in a lifetime (A FinnFic) cover

Patchwork heart

Logan centric fanfic that takes place a three years after season 7. He's back in NYC trying to launch a new business with his friends Colin and Finn. He's out from his father's grasp, trying to make it on his own, but his heart still has some mending to do from the way he left things with Rory. Unexpectedly the two will meet again, but with too much baggage between them, the two start off as friends - until one day that is no longer believable. Later might be switched to Mature rating.