Ana's Disappeared (Dark Secrets of the Craft)

Ana Stobol is a witch from Foxglove, Ohio. She lives with her five sisters and their grandmother Star in their old, Victorian house. Her favorite thing is to help people fall in love with her magical brownies while her sister Promise casts happy spells on the donuts that are cooked up daily at the bakery they run with their grandmother. They aren't aware of the power that they really possess. Star hasn't taught them what they are truly capable of because she wants to protect them from the same fate their parents suffered.

As oldest sister Ana approaches her twenty-fifth birthday and the blue full moon is coming, she disappears with a mysterious, beautiful stranger. The grandson, Aris Orologas, of her grandmother's guardian, Stavros. Ana didn't go willingly. She was compelled to go with Aris.
It becomes necessary to teach the remaining four sisters what it means to be a Stobol witch and who the Orologas brothers are. These men are sworn to protect them. They are their guardians. While doing so, they must find Ana and Aris before it's too late.

An ancient book will reveal long ago predictions about the five powerful witches and their destiny.
In the end, it becomes about their relationships with the Orologas brothers and what their true destiny is, revealed by the spirit of their dead mother. They must save their father from the underworld but will they fall in the love with their protectors? It is frowned upon by the witches' council for a guardian and a witch to fall in love. Their magic becomes too powerful to control.