Penelope "Penny" Arabella is a fifteen year old freshman at Fairfield, an elite all-girls school. She cannot stop thinking about Grace and Ali, and how much she wishes she had the confidence to talk to them... Or ask them out. She doesn't know if it's the fact that she hasn't actually held a normal conversation with a guy that took place outside of a dance ever, or if she really genuinely likes- loves?- these two girls. Maybe one more than the other. But she's still attracted to guys, too, so... what should she do?
Elliot Jensen and Elliot Fintry have a lot in common. They share the same name, the same house, the same school, oh and they hate each other but, as they will quickly learn, there is a fine line between love and hate.