After an epic summer bonfire Jay, Halley, Nathan, and Natalie stumble upon a crime scene. Before deciding that it would be too dangerous to stay any longer, they hear the detectives saying that the killer may not have been human. So, these four teens decide to investigate on their own. Discussions of cryptids and supernatural beings only make their curiosity stronger. Jay wholeheartedly believes that it was something supernatural, the others aren't as easily convinced.