That Smiling Idiot (Jeff the killer x reader)
nightmare_neko_666
  • Reads 484,464
  • Votes 14,701
  • Parts 62
  • Time 3h 45m
  • Reads 484,464
  • Votes 14,701
  • Parts 62
  • Time 3h 45m
nightmare_neko_666
Ongoing, First published Oct 30, 2017
creepypastajeffthekillerjeffthekillerxreaderkillermurderserialkillerwattys2019
Y/n is a popular serial killer with the catch phrase 'close your eyes and say goodbye', when she take the throne of most popular serial killer Jeff hunts her down. Will their rivalry turn into love? Or will they continue to try and kill each other?

Highest ranks I've ever been:
#1 creepypasta 
#1 jeffthekillerxreader 
#1 murder
#3 killer 

Omg thanks to everyone who has been reading this. slow updates and if you haven't read then please enjoy it
All Rights Reserved
creepypastajeffthekillerjeffthekillerxreaderkillermurderserialkillerwattys2019
Table of contents

62 parts

Sign up to add That Smiling Idiot (Jeff the killer x reader) to your library and receive updates
or
#179creepypasta
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Lovely - Jeff the Killer x Reader (🚧) by jeffsno1gf
30 parts Ongoing Mature
*CURRENTLY BEING REWRITTEN* "Do I scare you, detective?" "A little." "Why's that?" "Because you could kill me." "You're right, I could. But would I?" Jeff the Killer x Reader Foul language Violence Any creepypastas depicted + reader are all 20+ yrs old STARTED: 12/15/19 FINISHED:
The one that saved me (Jeff the killer x reader) by hazzthesazz3
11 parts Complete Mature
You the reader going on a quest to find out who you truly are. meeting Jeff the killer and the creepypasta family, would you want to go back to your original home or would you want to stay. many secrects are revealed as you continue to stay longer, do you belive in the truth or will the truth haunt you. looking at this now, this took me a whole year to make, comments would be greatly appreciated
The killers II by TiaraSkittlesKovacik
83 parts Complete
Continuation of the killers. Jeff has been in the hospital for five years after killing Jane. Will his regret cause him to do the unthinkable? Also join other creepypasta ships start to bloom
Devotion** Jeff The Killer X Reader by Gr3yB0n3s
30 parts Complete
Jeff the Killer X Reader..... Is there much else to say. This is my first fanfiction so please don't hate. The grammar may not be perfect but I tried. 0-0
Jeff The Killer x Reader Book One by _Jello_101_
18 parts Complete
This story is going to be about Y/N that feels like she dosent matter in life and no one loves her, she just feels like she is alone in life. Then one night as she is sleeping, Jeff brakes into her house and kills her whole family, and tries to kill her. Be aware, Its my first Creepypasta story, so just be slow with me, anyways, enjoy! Book started April 2nd, 2018 Book ended July 12th, 2018
'Be mine' (Jeff the Killer x Reader) by notesgrabs
30 parts Complete Mature
'"Jeff?" I ask. He didn't respond. I get up and walk to the door. He gets up and grabs his knife. "Jeff?!" I yell. "Shhhh no need to yell." He says. I look at him in horror. "It's okay doll, it'll only take a second." He says as he lunges at me. He stabs my stomach and I let out a blood curdling scream. I hold my stomach and try to get out of the room.' Started: March 15th, 2021 Status: Complete! I do not own any of the creepypasta characters, artwork, or music. (I'll say if anything is mine) I'm sorry if you read this. It absolutely sucks. Tell me if you notice something wrong so I can improve! Again, sorry.
Knives and Hearts - Creepypasta Jeff the Killer X Reader by SepticCyanide93
9 parts Complete Mature
The infamous crazed killer has been wreaking havoc, killing all across town and tonight it's your turn. But will you be too interesting to kill? More content from me besides what's on here? -My DeviantArt or FF.net. @ Linklove93. Also it is complete. There is a mature scene in a later chapter. Art belongs to it's respective artist, I take no credit for it.
Eyeless Jack X Jane The Killer: Murderous Love by SketchaCreeps
13 parts Complete Mature
Eyeless Jack is in love with the newest creepypasta. He knew he was from the moment he laid "eyes" on her. But she does not appreciate his advances, or comfort. Jane seems to have a history with Jeff The Killer, and Jack must stop them from butting heads, while also trying to win the stone cold heart of the new Killer. Can he make Jane fall in love? Or will her mysterious history with Jeff prevent her from noticing the eyeless demon? ************ All images in this story are put together by me, used by photos I found on the internet, and edited by me. All poetry in this story is written by my best friend Courtney Lesa Minto, and is completely her copyright works. I'd like to say a big thank you to her for being my editor and backbone during this story ❤️ @CourtneyLesa
The Rose Of Death ~~ Jeff The Killer X Gender Neutral Reader by Randomdude04
14 parts Complete Mature
Jeff the killer X gender neutral reader This book takes place in the early 2000's Y/n finds themselves in a very deathly situation, in a situation with a dangerous serial killer who is obsessed with them. How will this story end, will you have a good or a bad end to the story Reader is referred by they/them pronounce in this book
A Heart With No Beat (Yandere Jeff The Killer Fan Fiction) by IntrovertedWriter05
30 parts Complete
Y/N Is A Friendly Girl. She Always Stays Positive & Has An Over Protective Mother. She Never Has A Doubt In A World! Well, Until A Serial Killer By The Name Of Jeff The Killer That's Been Gossiped Around School. When Jeff The Killer Murders Y/N's Mother, He Starts To Take An Obsessive Liking To The Girl... Cover Not Made By Me
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Lovely - Jeff the Killer x Reader (🚧) cover
The one that saved me (Jeff the killer x reader) cover
The killers II cover
Devotion** Jeff The Killer X Reader cover
Jeff The Killer x Reader Book One cover
'Be mine' (Jeff the Killer x Reader) cover
Knives and Hearts - Creepypasta Jeff the Killer X Reader cover
Eyeless Jack X Jane The Killer: Murderous Love cover
The Rose Of Death ~~ Jeff The Killer X Gender Neutral Reader cover
A Heart With No Beat (Yandere Jeff The Killer Fan Fiction) cover

Lovely - Jeff the Killer x Reader (🚧)

30 parts Ongoing Mature

*CURRENTLY BEING REWRITTEN* "Do I scare you, detective?" "A little." "Why's that?" "Because you could kill me." "You're right, I could. But would I?" Jeff the Killer x Reader Foul language Violence Any creepypastas depicted + reader are all 20+ yrs old STARTED: 12/15/19 FINISHED:

More details