All's Fair in Love and Lucy - yukezai - Wattpad

All's Fair in Love and Lucy

Reads 72
Votes 4
Parts 4
Time 16m

Reads 72
Votes 4
Parts 4
Time 16m

anime erza fairyhigh fairytail fairytailretelling fanfiction gajeelredfox gale gray gruvia hiromashima jellal levymcgarden lucy manga nalu natsu romance school

The beginning quarter of Fairy High begins! Bookish Lucy Heartfilia's aspirations get turned upside down when she meets the rambunctious troublemaker Natsu Dragneel. Is Fairy High an accurate match to its reputation, or is there something more sinister bubbling under the surface?All Rights Reserved

anime erza fairyhigh fairytail fairytailretelling fanfiction gajeelredfox gale gray gruvia hiromashima jellal levymcgarden lucy manga nalu natsu romance school

Table of contents

4 parts

Sign up to add All's Fair in Love and Lucy to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Forgotten and Forgiveness by malzor82

If you asked someone at Fairytail High who Lucy Heartfelia was, they would have no idea. She is like a shadow, fitting in with the crowd. Lucy has never spoken to anyone or shown her face. Because she is bullied by Natsu Dragneel, the hottest, coolest, smartest guy in the school. He torments her to death. Taking her diary, and reading it in front of the cafeteria, posting flyers up all over the school of a terrible altered photo of her, and giving her mental and physical beat downs. The only thing is, every time Natsu does something horrible, she tolerates it, and forgives him. Because Natsu hit his head one day, and forgot about her. Forgot about them being best friends. (I recently read this story over again and it is FREAKING SO DEPRESSING...all except for the ending. A lot of things happen very quickly but just bind with me.)

The Blind One by LLBK731

this fanfiction is about Natsu and Lucy Natsu is a popular kid and has many friends in school. he is in a group with Erza, Jellal, Gajeel, Levy, Gray and Juvia. Lucy is a Blind girl and has no friends due to her condition she is also the new girl in FairyTail High. one day lucy bumps into natsu at school. and thats when the friendship start. I DO NOT OWN FAIRY FAIL CHARACTERS THEY BELING TO HIRO MASHIMA

Fairy Tail: You're Lucy of Fairy Tail. (A NaLu Fan Fiction) by Cryptic_Eyes

- - - - Lucy is a passerby, stopping in the town of Magnolia to replenish herself before continuing on her lonely journey. She has a rare form of magic; Celestial Mage Magic. She's the only one who possesses such, but it's considered a disgusted magic to mages. When Lucy Heartfilia meets Natsu Dragneel of Fairy Tail, she realizes he's someone she can rely on for once in her life. However, the rest of Fairy Tail is a little more skeptical. Though Lucy begins to fit in with the guild and people begin to realize she's not so bad, there is something else brewing; a protective Natsu, who is falling for the unstable mage Lucy Heartfilia. But when Lucy get's taken away, will it be enough for the guild to go and rescue her? Yet, why would she be taken away in the first place? Find out in a story that has never been done before! An alternate meeting of Lucy Heartfilia and the Fairy Tail guild; a different reality than the one and only true Fairy Tail belonging to Hiro Mashima in Fairy Tail: You're Lucy of Fairy Tail!

When we meet again by Jade_Cole

"Natsu, you make me happy. And I don't know how I could've gotten through this week without you. Even with me not being able to speak you didn't plead with me to get me to talk or force me to talk. It made me love you even more for that." I paused for a moment, feeling the lump in my throat form, signaling that I was going to cry again. I took a shaky breath and looked at him with pleading eyes. "I don't know how I'm going to get through how ever long it is until I see you again. Please convince your parents to come with me! Please Natsu!" After Lucy and Natsu had just confessed their love for each other. Lucy finds out that her parents pass away in a fatal car accident. A week later after being taken in by the Dragneel family, on Natsu's thirteenth birthday, Lucy's sister Michelle comes to take Lucy home with her to Paris to live with her and her husband. Lucy stays in Paris, only keeping in touch with one friend during her four years there. On her sixteenth birthday, Lucy finally moves back to Magnolia. With Natsu heavy on her mind, she gets a job and begins attending the same high school as Natsu. What happens when they get assigned to be partners on a school project after not speaking for four long years? And finding out she just happens to have gotten a job at the same place Natsu works? Will their love blossom as quickly as when they were twelve? Or will they never be meant to be with each other ever again. Find out in When We Meet Again. **I don't own any of these characters, only the plot of this story. The characters belong to Fairy Tails creator Hiro Mashima. I reserve all rights to said creator.** Published: 12/4/22 Finished: 9/23/23 Rankings: #14 nalu4ever 6/1/25 #20 levy 5/27/25 #21 juvia 5/27/25 #33 gajeel 5/27/25 #24 jerza 5/28/25 #164 nalu 4/14/25

l Love You But Do You? (Nalu Fanfiction) by salinaguo

Lucy Heartfillia is your average teenage girl that wants to go to Fairy Tail, one of the best schools in magnolia, with an average life until her mother dies and her father starts to ignore her blaming her for her mother's death. Natsu Dragneel is an average teenage boy that attends Fairy Tail High and life couldn't be any better for Dragneel but with the death of his mother, he turns cold and doesn't trust anyone except for a few friends. Will Natsu's heart warm-up for Lucy or will she be yet just another girl who attends Fairy Tail? The sequel to this book, Meant To Be? is now published! Highest Ranking: #1 nalufanfiction #1 Jerza #2 Nalu #2 Jellal #3 Levy Credits go to the real creator of Fairy Tail Hiro Mashima.

The Playboy of Fairy Tail High by sleepingintheshadows

AU/OOC Natsu Dragneel is the well-known playboy of Fairy Tail High. But will his demeanor change when the new transfer with good intentions, Lucy Heartfilia, makes her way to his heart? What does Lucy think? "'Found a way to his heart'?! I wasn't trying to get to his heart! I was warned about Natsu, don't get me caught in this! Waaaaa!" Lucy, who lived in a distant city, moved to become a student at Fairy Tail High, a boarding school in the city of Magnolia. She was pen pals with Levy McGarden before finally moving away from her family to join FTH. But even she holds secrets in this crazy school. What does Natsu think? "Luce is a cool girl. She didn't immediately fall for me, which made her an interesting project." "I HEARD THAT!" "I- uh- mean that, I wanted to get to know her better! Yeah, that." *This is my first NaLu fanfic, but I'm a huge fan! I'm sorry if this story sounds a lot like other FT in a High School stories, but it's all my imagination! Also not as cliché as it sounds!! :3 *also, sorry if the summary sucks :P DISCLAIMER: Hiro Mashima owns Fairy Tail and the characters, for which I thank him, because FT is amazing! <3 I own the plot to this story please comment, tell me what you think! [STARTED: (before posting here) March 11, '15] [FINISHED: (around) June 28, '15] [UNDER SERIOUS EDITING]

Secrets - NALU by jerrift

Lucy Heartfillia is a young and beautiful girl. She is an elite general of the capital army of Magnolia. She has a caring father, friends, and is very rich. Natsu Dragneel is a handsome and rich, salmon haired teen without a care in the world. Girls fawn over him. He thinks he has his life set ahead of, as he is going to be the heir of the company after he finishes high school. Lucy's friends suggest she attends school, since she hasn't had the experience or ever gone to a public school. She ends up going to Fairy Tail High School. When both of them collide, what is bound happen? // Took less than a few hours to create this, so generally it's filled with plot holes + poor grammar. It'll be edited soon //

He Likes You (A Fairy Tail High Fanfic) by AriesTheRam156

Lucy and Erza are new students at Fairy Tail High and stick together. They find themselves a group of great friends to hang with. They soon fall in love with 2 particularly hot guys but are helpless. Lucy is too dense to realize anything and Erza is shy around most guys (like rly shy). Will these relationships work out or will Lucy and Erza be left heartbroken? Read to find out! ♡♡

We Fit Together by animefreaak

Natsu Dragneel has always had strange rumors floating around about him at school. A new girl named Lucy Heartfilia sees him in her class and they become close friends almost instantly despite the differences in their personalities. Drama ensues as their complicated lives get tangled together and their friendship develops into something more. NaLu fanfiction BEWARE: some characters will be OOC because this is a AU fanfic and their situations in life are different. Hmm I suck at writing descriptions so yeh (FINALLY COMPLETED)

✔️He Dared Me! - NaLu -✔️ by Kara005

Life is normal in Fairy Tail High until a new student transfers. Lucy Heartfilia, the rich nerd who has a handful of friends and thousands of enemies. When she meets Natsu Dragneel, his crazy personality flips her world upside-down - until one dare changes everything. The deal - date Lucy for a month and then rip her heart out. It's a simple task for the most popular guy in the school. (Completed 22/10/18)

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Forgotten and Forgiveness cover

The Blind One cover

Fairy Tail: You're Lucy of Fairy Tail. (A NaLu Fan Fiction) cover

When we meet again cover

l Love You But Do You? (Nalu Fanfiction) cover

The Playboy of Fairy Tail High cover

Secrets - NALU cover

He Likes You (A Fairy Tail High Fanfic) cover

We Fit Together cover

✔️He Dared Me! - NaLu -✔️ cover

Forgotten and Forgiveness

If you asked someone at Fairytail High who Lucy Heartfelia was, they would have no idea. She is like a shadow, fitting in with the crowd. Lucy has never spoken to anyone or shown her face. Because she is bullied by Natsu Dragneel, the hottest, coolest, smartest guy in the school. He torments her to death. Taking her diary, and reading it in front of the cafeteria, posting flyers up all over the school of a terrible altered photo of her, and giving her mental and physical beat downs. The only thing is, every time Natsu does something horrible, she tolerates it, and forgives him. Because Natsu hit his head one day, and forgot about her. Forgot about them being best friends. (I recently read this story over again and it is FREAKING SO DEPRESSING...all except for the ending. A lot of things happen very quickly but just bind with me.)